School InsightsBeta · Michigan

Charter vs. traditional public schools, like for like

Charter schools often serve different students than the public school down the street, so comparing their rankings straight up misleads. Here each Michigan charter elementary school is set only against traditional public schools serving a similar share of low-income students.

At first glance

Charter31st
Traditional54th

Typical school's statewide percentile. On raw rankings, the typical charter school ranks 23 points lower. But they serve different students, so that's not a fair fight.

Like for like

+3 points

Compared with traditional public schools serving similar students, charter schools rank 3 percentile points higher.

Side by side, among schools serving similar students

It depends on the neighborhood: charter schools trail where under 20% of students are low-income (−13) and lead where 80% or more are (+6).

  • Typical charter school
  • Typical traditional public school
  • Middle half of traditional schools
  • Each charter school
Under 20%4 charter · 137 traditional
93rd80th
−13 charter
20–39%17 charter · 259 traditional
75th78th
+3 charter
40–59%15 charter · 239 traditional
55th57th
About even
60–79%19 charter · 236 traditional
34th32nd
About even
80% or more70 charter · 195 traditional
12th18th
+6 charter

Statewide percentile in the 2025-26 rankings, all students. Point at a dot to see the school; click it to keep its card open.

Not shown: virtual schools (19 ranked, but only 3 report a low-income figure). A fair comparison needs at least 10 elementary schools of a type with a low-income figure.

Charter schools that do best for the students they serve

Ranked by how far each school sits above the typical traditional public school serving a similar share of low-income students.

SchoolLow-incomeStatewidevs. similar traditional
Pembroke AcademyDetroit 85% 92nd +80
Hamtramck AcademyHamtramck 96% 78th +66
Vanderbilt Charter AcademyHolland 81% 67th +55
Noor International AcademySterling Heights 60% 88th +54
Star International AcademyCanton 88% 61st +49
Cross Creek Charter AcademyByron Center 41% 96th +41
Windemere Park Charter AcademyLansing 86% 51st +39
Hanley International AcademyHamtramck 96% 49th +37
Detroit Edison Public School AcademyDetroit 74% 69th +35
Three Lakes AcademyCurtis 62% 69th +35
Every charter school, in numbers (125)
SchoolLow-incomeStatewidevs. similar traditional
Pembroke AcademyDetroit 85% 92nd +80
Hamtramck AcademyHamtramck 96% 78th +66
Vanderbilt Charter AcademyHolland 81% 67th +55
Noor International AcademySterling Heights 60% 88th +54
Star International AcademyCanton 88% 61st +49
Cross Creek Charter AcademyByron Center 41% 96th +41
Windemere Park Charter AcademyLansing 86% 51st +39
Hanley International AcademyHamtramck 96% 49th +37
Detroit Edison Public School AcademyDetroit 74% 69th +35
Three Lakes AcademyCurtis 62% 69th +35
Great Oaks AcademyWarren 91% 47th +35
Ridge Park Charter AcademyGrand Rapids 91% 46th +34
Muskegon Montessori Academy for Environmental ChangeNorton Shores 81% 46th +34
South Canton Scholars Charter AcademyCanton 47% 88th +33
Paragon Charter AcademyJackson 64% 67th +33
Vanguard Charter AcademyWyoming 59% 87th +32
Endeavor Charter AcademyBattle Creek 82% 44th +32
Prevail AcademyMount Clemens 91% 43rd +31
Keystone AcademyBelleville 53% 84th +29
Walker Charter AcademyGrand Rapids 54% 82nd +27
Triumph AcademyMonroe 61% 61st +27
Burton Glen Charter AcademyBurton 95% 38th +26
Vista Charter AcademyGrand Rapids 93% 38th +26
Knapp Charter AcademyGrand Rapids 77% 59th +25
Chandler Woods Charter AcademyBelmont 36% 99th +24
Quest Charter AcademyTaylor 85% 36th +24
Laurus AcademySouthfield 83% 36th +24
Legacy Charter AcademyDetroit 97% 35th +23
The James and Grace Lee Boggs SchoolDetroit 69% 55th +21
South Arbor Charter AcademyYpsilanti 32% 95th +20
Walden Green MontessoriSpring Lake 26% 94th +19
Holly AcademyHolly 20% 93rd +18
Linden Charter AcademyFlint 92% 30th +18
Eagle Crest Charter AcademyHolland 65% 51st +17
Grand Rapids Child Discovery CenterGrand Rapids 29% 91st +16
New Paradigm GlazerLoving AcademyDetroit 93% 28th +16
Detroit Enterprise AcademyDetroit 89% 28th +16
Achieve Charter AcademyCanton 29% 90th +15
East Shore Leadership AcademyPort Huron 93% 27th +15
Walton Charter AcademyPontiac 92% 27th +15
Gerald Dawkins AcademyGrand Rapids 97% 26th +14
Fortis AcademyYpsilanti 89% 26th +14
River City Scholars Charter AcademyGrand Rapids 96% 25th +13
Holly Park AcademyLansing 91% 25th +13
Warrendale Charter AcademyDetroit 97% 24th +12
Paramount Charter AcademyKalamazoo 95% 24th +12
North Saginaw Charter AcademySaginaw 95% 24th +12
Detroit PrepDetroit 55% 66th +11
Detroit Achievement AcademyDetroit 84% 23rd +11
Canton Charter AcademyCanton 35% 85th +10
Chatfield SchoolLapeer 24% 85th +10
Taylor Exemplar AcademyTaylor 77% 44th +10
Madison Academy ElementaryMiddle SchoolFlint 96% 22nd +10
Countryside Academy ElementaryBenton Harbor 83% 21st +9
New Branches Charter AcademyGrand Rapids 89% 20th +8
Reach Charter AcademyRoseville 87% 20th +8
Detroit Merit Charter AcademyDetroit 82% 20th +8
Plymouth Scholars Charter AcademyPlymouth 19% 99th +6
Commonwealth Community Development AcademyHamtramck 93% 18th +6
Woodland Park AcademyGrand Blanc 84% 18th +6
Island City AcademyEaton Rapids 45% 60th +5
Northridge AcademyFlint 98% 17th +5
Grand River AcademyLivonia 81% 17th +5
Inkster Preparatory AcademyInkster 94% 16th +4
Westfield Charter AcademyRedford 83% 16th +4
Woodland SchoolTraverse City 22% 78th +3
Da Vinci Schools K5Jackson 80% 15th +3
North Star Montessori AcademyMarquette 49% 57th +2
Redford Service Learning Academy CampusRedford 98% 14th +2
Flagship Charter AcademyDetroit 94% 14th +2
The Dearborn AcademyDearborn 94% 13th +1
Weston Preparatory AcademyDetroit 85% 13th +1
Old Mission Peninsula SchoolTraverse City 22% 75th 0
Black River Public School ElementaryHolland 20% 74th −1
Grand Blanc AcademyGrand Blanc 96% 11th −1
Detroit Leadership Academy K8Detroit 91% 11th −1
West Village AcademyDearborn 86% 11th −1
Cole AcademyLansing 67% 32nd −2
Timberland Charter AcademyMuskegon 97% 10th −2
Innocademy Allegan CampusFennville 76% 31st −3
Metro Charter AcademyRomulus 69% 31st −3
Detroit Premier AcademyDetroit 91% 9th −3
Dove Academy of DetroitDetroit 86% 9th −3
South Pointe Scholars Charter AcademyYpsilanti 74% 30th −4
Michigan Collegiate ElementaryRoseville 93% 8th −4
Dr Joseph F Pollack Academic Center of ExcellenceSouthfield 82% 8th −4
Eaton AcademyEastpointe 80% 8th −4
East Arbor Charter AcademyYpsilanti 69% 29th −5
Macomb Montessori AcademyWarren 97% 7th −5
Chandler Park Academy ElementaryHarper Woods 94% 7th −5
Detroit Innovation AcademyDetroit 87% 7th −5
University Preparatory Elementary Ellen Thompson CampusDetroit 82% 7th −5
Mill Creek AcademyWilliamsburg 25% 69th −6
Discovery Creative Pathways Harper WoodsHarper Woods 88% 6th −6
WashingtonParks AcademyRedford 90% 5th −7
Voyageur AcademyDetroit 97% 4th −8
Global Heights AcademyDearborn Heights 95% 4th −8
MacDowell Preparatory AcademyDetroit 91% 4th −8
MadisonCarver AcademyDetroit 86% 4th −8
Saginaw Preparatory AcademySaginaw 97% 3rd −9
Mt Clemens Montessori AcademyMount Clemens 36% 65th −10
Barack Obama Leadership AcademyDetroit 92% 2nd −10
West Michigan Academy of Arts and AcademicsSpring Lake 58% 43rd −12
Academy of WarrenWarren 97% 1st −12
Barber Elementary SchoolHighland Park 95% 1st −12
AdamsYoung BuildingDetroit 87% 1st −12
Old Redford Academy ElementaryDetroit 85% 1st −12
Charyl Stockwell AcademyHowell 15% 80th −13
Joseph K Lumsden Bahweting Anishnabe AcademySault Sainte Marie 50% 42nd −13
Creative Montessori AcademySouthgate 61% 21st −13
Honey Creek Community SchoolAnn Arbor 10% 79th −14
Four Corners Montessori AcademyMadison Heights 46% 41st −14
University Preparatory Elementary Mark Murray CampusDetroit 74% 20th −14
University Prep Science and Math Elementary Miller CampusDetroit 71% 20th −14
Lake Superior AcademySault Sainte Marie 42% 39th −16
Summit Academy North Elementary SchoolRomulus 73% 17th −17
University Preparatory Art Design ElementaryDetroit 79% 13th −21
Cole Academy EastEast Lansing 54% 33rd −22
Oakland AcademyPortage 37% 52nd −23
Renaissance Public School AcademyMount Pleasant 59% 32nd −23
Light of the World AcademyPinckney 31% 48th −27
Branch Line SchoolLivonia 49% 24th −31
Waterford Montessori AcademyWaterford 39% 38th −37
Waterford Montessori AcademyWaterford 39% 35th −40
Kingsbury Country Day SchoolOxford 18% 47th −46

How this works

Why not just compare rankings?
Test scores track family income closely. If one kind of school serves more low-income students, it will rank lower even if it teaches just as well. So schools are first sorted into five groups by their share of low-income students (free or reduced-price lunch), and each charter school is compared only with traditional public schools in its own group.
Reading a row
The purple dot is the typical (median) charter school in that group, the gray dot the typical traditional public school; the number on the right is the gap between them in statewide percentile points. The gray bar shows where the middle half of traditional schools rank, so you can see how much schools vary.
The like-for-like number
The row gaps, averaged and weighted by how many charter schools each group holds. Groups with fewer than 3charter schools or 5 traditional schools are left out of it. It describes typical schools, not any one school; the dots show how widely charter schools differ from each other.
What's left out
Private schools, schools without a low-income figure, and schools too new or too small to rank. Rankings come from state test scores, one measure of a school. Read how SchoolDigger ranks schools.

Diagnostics