School InsightsBeta · Michigan

Magnet vs. traditional public schools, like for like

Magnet schools often serve different students than the public school down the street, so comparing their rankings straight up misleads. Here each Michigan magnet elementary school is set only against traditional public schools serving a similar share of low-income students.

At first glance

Magnet50th
Traditional54th

Typical school's statewide percentile. On raw rankings, the typical magnet school ranks 4 points lower.

Like for like

About even

Compared with traditional public schools serving similar students, magnet schools rank about the same.

Side by side, among schools serving similar students

It depends on the neighborhood: magnet schools trail where 60–79% of students are low-income (−6) and lead where 20–39% are (+5).

  • Typical magnet school
  • Typical traditional public school
  • Middle half of traditional schools
  • Each magnet school
Under 20%15 magnet · 137 traditional
93rd92nd
About even
20–39%17 magnet · 259 traditional
75th80th
+5 magnet
40–59%46 magnet · 239 traditional
55th51st
−4 magnet
60–79%21 magnet · 236 traditional
34th28th
−6 magnet
80% or more34 magnet · 195 traditional
12th13th
About even

Statewide percentile in the 2025-26 rankings, all students. Point at a dot to see the school; click it to keep its card open.

Not shown: virtual schools (19 ranked, but only 3 report a low-income figure). A fair comparison needs at least 10 elementary schools of a type with a low-income figure.

Magnet schools that do best for the students they serve

Ranked by how far each school sits above the typical traditional public school serving a similar share of low-income students.

SchoolLow-incomeStatewidevs. similar traditional
Highview Elementary SchoolDearborn Heights 89% 76th +64
Hillcrest Elementary SchoolDearborn Heights 83% 72nd +60
Weidman Elementary SchoolWeidman 73% 92nd +58
Kinloch Elementary SchoolDearborn Heights 72% 89th +55
Handley SchoolSaginaw 43% 97th +42
NorwayVulcan Elementary SchoolNorway 40% 91st +36
Deckerville Elementary SchoolDeckerville 67% 69th +35
Sharp Park AcademyJackson 60% 69th +35
University Elementary School AcademyLathrup Village 43% 89th +34
Hale Creek Elementary SchoolRomulus 90% 45th +33
Every magnet school, in numbers (133)
SchoolLow-incomeStatewidevs. similar traditional
Highview Elementary SchoolDearborn Heights 89% 76th +64
Hillcrest Elementary SchoolDearborn Heights 83% 72nd +60
Weidman Elementary SchoolWeidman 73% 92nd +58
Kinloch Elementary SchoolDearborn Heights 72% 89th +55
Handley SchoolSaginaw 43% 97th +42
NorwayVulcan Elementary SchoolNorway 40% 91st +36
Deckerville Elementary SchoolDeckerville 67% 69th +35
Sharp Park AcademyJackson 60% 69th +35
University Elementary School AcademyLathrup Village 43% 89th +34
Hale Creek Elementary SchoolRomulus 90% 45th +33
Wick Elementary SchoolRomulus 81% 45th +33
Northglade Montessori SchoolKalamazoo 46% 87th +32
Brendel Elementary SchoolGrand Blanc 64% 64th +30
Central Park Elementary SchoolMidland 62% 64th +30
Barth Elementary SchoolRomulus 75% 63rd +29
Romulus Elementary SchoolRomulus 81% 41st +29
Bedford SchoolDearborn Heights 82% 39th +27
Ottawa Elementary SchoolPetoskey 41% 80th +25
Post Oak SchoolLansing 66% 56th +22
Holly AcademyHolly 20% 93rd +18
Andrews Elementary SchoolThree Rivers 48% 73rd +18
Sheridan SchoolPetoskey 27% 91st +16
Harbor Beach Elementary SchoolHarbor Beach 53% 71st +16
Eastside Connections SchoolNiles 51% 71st +16
West Bendle Elementary SchoolBurton 92% 28th +16
Belle River Elementary SchoolMarine City 53% 70th +15
Marie C Graham Elementary SchoolHarrison Township 60% 48th +14
Greenfield Elementary SchoolBeverly Hills 26% 87th +12
Siebert Elementary SchoolMidland 27% 86th +11
Dodson Elementary SchoolCanton 20% 86th +11
Elva Lynch Elementary SchoolLapeer 54% 66th +11
Lincoln Heights Elementary SchoolGreenville 50% 66th +11
Woodcrest Elementary SchoolMidland 28% 85th +10
Plymouth Elementary SchoolMidland 51% 64th +9
East Jackson ElementaryJackson 84% 21st +9
Pine River Elementary SchoolChina 28% 83rd +8
Lakeland Elementary SchoolColdwater 69% 42nd +8
New Branches Charter AcademyGrand Rapids 89% 20th +8
Lincoln SchoolPetoskey 30% 82nd +7
EB Holman Elementary SchoolAtlantic Mine 56% 62nd +7
Hemmeter Elementary SchoolSaginaw 12% 99th +6
Joseph C Sterling Elementary SchoolCarleton 46% 61st +6
Commonwealth Community Development AcademyHamtramck 93% 18th +6
Pierce Elementary SchoolBirmingham 5% 98th +5
Palms Elementary SchoolIra 27% 80th +5
Saint Clair River ElementarySaint Clair 41% 60th +5
Sequoyah Elementary SchoolMacomb 20% 79th +4
Saranac Elementary SchoolSaranac 44% 59th +4
Edison AcademyKalamazoo 96% 16th +4
Pattengill SchoolLansing 89% 16th +4
Wexford Montessori Magnet SchoolLansing 84% 16th +4
Harlan Elementary SchoolBloomfield Hills 6% 96th +3
Cherokee Elementary SchoolClinton Twp 40% 58th +3
Polk Elementary SchoolDearborn Heights 85% 15th +3
Spring Valley Center for ExplorationKalamazoo 84% 15th +3
Ada Vista Elementary SchoolAda 7% 95th +2
South River Elementary SchoolHarrison Township 35% 77th +2
Adams Elementary SchoolMidland 28% 77th +2
Central Elementary SchoolPetoskey 27% 77th +2
Beverly Elementary SchoolBeverly Hills 8% 94th +1
Woodward ElementaryKalamazoo 93% 13th +1
Cascades Elementary SchoolJackson 91% 13th +1
Covert Elementary SchoolCovert 81% 13th +1
Bingham Farms Elementary SchoolBingham Farms 15% 93rd 0
West Maple Elementary SchoolBloomfield Hills 10% 93rd 0
Waldron Elementary and Middle SchoolFowler 18% 92nd −1
Quarton ElementaryBirmingham 2% 92nd −1
Shepherd Elementary SchoolShepherd 57% 54th −1
Chestnut Hill Elementary SchoolMidland 42% 54th −1
Nolan ElementaryMiddle SchoolDetroit 95% 11th −1
West Village AcademyDearborn 86% 11th −1
William A Pearson ElementarySouth Lyon 16% 91st −2
Pembroke Elementary SchoolTroy 15% 91st −2
Page Elementary SchoolMiddleville 44% 53rd −2
Hunt Elementary SchoolJackson 95% 10th −2
East Jordan Elementary SchoolEast Jordan 58% 52nd −3
Ruth Hoppin SchoolThree Rivers 47% 52nd −3
Alcona Elementary SchoolHarrisville 81% 9th −3
Algonquin Elementary SchoolClay 57% 51st −4
Ojibwa Elementary SchoolMacomb 43% 51st −4
Arthur Eddy AcademySaginaw 97% 8th −4
Dr Joseph F Pollack Academic Center of ExcellenceSouthfield 82% 8th −4
Lake Ann Elementary SchoolInterlochen 50% 50th −5
Huron Elementary SchoolClinton Twp 41% 50th −5
University Preparatory Elementary Ellen Thompson CampusDetroit 82% 7th −5
Maplewood SchoolVermontville 61% 28th −6
Washington Writers AcademyKalamazoo 94% 6th −6
Cheyenne Elementary SchoolMacomb 25% 68th −7
Homestead Hills Elementary SchoolBenzonia 63% 27th −7
Mary McLeod Bethune ElementaryMiddle SchoolDetroit 92% 5th −7
Grayson ElementaryWaterford 54% 47th −8
Lincoln International Studies SchoolKalamazoo 81% 4th −8
Sault Area Elementary SchoolSault Sainte Marie 53% 46th −9
Woods Lake ElementaryA Magnet Center For The ArtsKalamazoo 79% 25th −9
Saginaw Preparatory AcademySaginaw 97% 3rd −9
Dwight Rich School of the ArtsLansing 93% 3rd −9
Tyrone Elementary SchoolHarper Woods 89% 3rd −9
Ferndale Upper Elementary CampusOak Park 45% 45th −10
Betsie Valley SchoolThompsonville 71% 24th −10
Onaway Elementary SchoolOnaway 63% 24th −10
Miami Elementary SchoolClinton Twp 53% 44th −11
Potter SchoolFlint 95% 1st −11
Vestaburg Community Elementary SchoolVestaburg 48% 43rd −12
Martin G Atkins Elementary SchoolSaginaw 97% 1st −12
Old Redford Academy ElementaryDetroit 85% 1st −12
Mohawk Elementary SchoolMacomb 26% 62nd −13
El Sol ElementaryKalamazoo 57% 42nd −13
KND ElementaryBrethren 77% 21st −13
University Preparatory Elementary Mark Murray CampusDetroit 74% 20th −14
Workman Elementary SchoolCanton 11% 78th −15
Beaverton Elementary SchoolBeaverton 57% 40th −15
Holland Language Academy at Van RaalteHolland 48% 40th −15
Brick Elementary SchoolYpsilanti 71% 19th −15
Cardinal ElementaryMuskegon 71% 19th −15
Fox Elementary SchoolMacomb 51% 38th −17
Pardee SchoolDearborn Heights 77% 17th −17
Tenniswood Elementary SchoolClinton Township 71% 17th −17
Emma V Lobbestael Elementary SchoolHarrison Township 36% 57th −18
Reynolds Elementary SchoolReading 57% 37th −18
NijiIro Japanese Immersion Elementary SchoolLivonia 9% 74th −19
Central Elementary SchoolWhite Pigeon 51% 36th −19
Shawnee Elementary SchoolMacomb 19% 72nd −21
Frank E Bartlett SchoolSouth Lyon 18% 71st −22
Hillman Elementary SchoolHillman 49% 33rd −22
George D Gilbert Elementary SchoolGwinn 56% 32nd −23
Tyler Road Elementary SchoolBelleville 54% 29th −26
Childs Elementary SchoolYpsilanti 53% 28th −27
Fremont International AcademyBattle Creek 54% 26th −29
Ottawa Elementary SchoolClinton Twp 50% 25th −30
Clinton Valley Elementary SchoolMount Clemens 58% 23rd −32
Erie Elementary SchoolClinton Twp 36% 39th −36
Bishop Elementary SchoolYpsilanti 57% 16th −39
Potterville Elementary SchoolPotterville 45% 10th −45

How this works

Why not just compare rankings?
Test scores track family income closely. If one kind of school serves more low-income students, it will rank lower even if it teaches just as well. So schools are first sorted into five groups by their share of low-income students (free or reduced-price lunch), and each magnet school is compared only with traditional public schools in its own group.
Reading a row
The purple dot is the typical (median) magnet school in that group, the gray dot the typical traditional public school; the number on the right is the gap between them in statewide percentile points. The gray bar shows where the middle half of traditional schools rank, so you can see how much schools vary.
The like-for-like number
The row gaps, averaged and weighted by how many magnet schools each group holds. Groups with fewer than 3magnet schools or 5 traditional schools are left out of it. It describes typical schools, not any one school; the dots show how widely magnet schools differ from each other.
What's left out
Private schools, schools without a low-income figure, and schools too new or too small to rank. Rankings come from state test scores, one measure of a school. Read how SchoolDigger ranks schools.

Diagnostics