School InsightsBeta · Ohio

Charter vs. traditional public schools, like for like

Charter schools often serve different students than the public school down the street, so comparing their rankings straight up misleads. Here each Ohio charter elementary school is set only against traditional public schools serving a similar share of low-income students.

At first glance

Charter19th
Traditional29th

Typical school's statewide percentile. On raw rankings, the typical charter school ranks 10 points lower.

Like for like

−6 points

Compared with traditional public schools serving similar students, charter schools rank 6 percentile points lower.

Side by side, among schools serving similar students

It depends on the neighborhood: charter schools trail where 20–39% of students are low-income (−52) and lead where 80% or more are (+7).

  • Typical charter school
  • Typical traditional public school
  • Middle half of traditional schools
  • Each charter school
Under 20%0 charter · 2 traditional
No charter schools
20–39%10 charter · 44 traditional
71st19th
−52 charter
40–59%15 charter · 163 traditional
44th24th
−20 charter
60–79%58 charter · 220 traditional
26th20th
−6 charter
80% or more52 charter · 138 traditional
12th19th
+7 charter

Statewide percentile in the 2025-26 rankings, all students. Point at a dot to see the school; click it to keep its card open.

Not shown: magnet schools (no ranked school is marked magnet in the federal school data); virtual schools (7 ranked, too few to compare). A fair comparison needs at least 10 elementary schools of a type with a low-income figure.

Charter schools that do best for the students they serve

Ranked by how far each school sits above the typical traditional public school serving a similar share of low-income students.

SchoolLow-incomeStatewidevs. similar traditional
Northland Preparatory and Fitness AcademyColumbus 85% 99th +87
Ohio College Preparatory SchoolMaple Heights 98% 82nd +70
Columbus Performance AcademyColumbus 89% 75th +63
Alliance Academy of CincinnatiCincinnati 89% 63rd +51
Niles Preparatory AcademyNiles 72% 69th +43
STEAM Academy of WarrenWarren 77% 64th +38
South Columbus Preparatory Academy at SouthfieldColumbus 63% 62nd +36
Northstar School of Innovation & LeadershipCleveland 98% 46th +34
Mt. Healthy Preparatory and Fitness AcademyCincinnati 62% 58th +32
Performance Academy EastlandColumbus 60% 55th +29
Every charter school, in numbers (135)
SchoolLow-incomeStatewidevs. similar traditional
Northland Preparatory and Fitness AcademyColumbus 85% 99th +87
Ohio College Preparatory SchoolMaple Heights 98% 82nd +70
Columbus Performance AcademyColumbus 89% 75th +63
Alliance Academy of CincinnatiCincinnati 89% 63rd +51
Niles Preparatory AcademyNiles 72% 69th +43
STEAM Academy of WarrenWarren 77% 64th +38
South Columbus Preparatory Academy at SouthfieldColumbus 63% 62nd +36
Northstar School of Innovation & LeadershipCleveland 98% 46th +34
Mt. Healthy Preparatory and Fitness AcademyCincinnati 62% 58th +32
Performance Academy EastlandColumbus 60% 55th +29
Cesar Chavez College Preparatory SchoolColumbus 74% 54th +28
STEAM Academy of Warrensville HeightsWarrensville Heights 60% 54th +28
Innovation Academy WestCleveland 95% 39th +27
Southside AcademyYoungstown 96% 37th +25
Par Excellence Academy dba Par Excellence STEM AcademyNewark 85% 36th +24
Cleveland Arts and Social Sciences AcademyCleveland 75% 48th +22
Dublin Preparatory Academy dba Northside Preparatory AcademyCincinnati 81% 32nd +20
South Scioto AcademyColumbus 75% 45th +19
Pathway School of DiscoveryDayton 64% 45th +19
Cleveland Preparatory AcademyCleveland 84% 31st +19
Westside AcademyColumbus 82% 29th +17
Youngstown Preparatory AcademyYoungstown 71% 42nd +16
Stambaugh Charter AcademyYoungstown 87% 28th +16
Broadway AcademyCleveland 46% 59th +15
Youngstown Community SchoolYoungstown 85% 27th +15
International Academy Of ColumbusColumbus 78% 40th +14
Orion AcademyCincinnati 85% 26th +14
Horizon Science Academy YoungstownYoungstown 70% 39th +13
Rise & Shine AcademyToledo 97% 25th +13
Imagine Leadership AcademyAkron 92% 25th +13
Springfield Preparatory and Fitness AcademySpringfield 82% 25th +13
Emerson AcademyDayton 80% 25th +13
Toledo Preparatory and Fitness AcademyToledo 61% 37th +11
Winterfield Venture AcademyToledo 84% 23rd +11
Horizon Science Academy-SpringfieldToledo 69% 36th +10
Miami Valley AcademiesDayton 93% 22nd +10
Constellation Schools: Westside Community School of the ArtsCleveland 85% 22nd +10
Apex AcademyCleveland 77% 35th +9
Stepstone AcademyCleveland 93% 21st +9
Trotwood Preparatory & Fitness AcademyTrotwood 93% 21st +9
Constellation Schools: Westpark Community ElementaryCleveland 78% 34th +8
Renaissance Academy dba Bessie Sherrod Price Preparatory AcademyColumbus 98% 20th +8
Foundation AcademyMansfield 85% 20th +8
North Dayton School of DiscoveryDayton 74% 33rd +7
Cincinnati Achievement AcademyCincinnati 94% 19th +7
Bennett Venture AcademyToledo 94% 19th +7
Klepinger Community SchoolDayton 82% 19th +7
L. Hollingworth School for Talented and GiftedToledo 68% 31st +5
Noble Academy-ClevelandEuclid 63% 31st +5
Phoenix Village Academy Primary 2 dba Wings Academy 1Cleveland 97% 17th +5
Lincoln Park AcademyCleveland 71% 30th +4
Ohio Achievement Charter Schools Inc. dba Millennium CommunColumbus 91% 16th +4
Lorain Preparatory AcademyLorain 89% 16th +4
Monroe Preparatory AcademySandusky 73% 28th +2
Cincinnati Technology AcademyCincinnati 98% 14th +2
SunBridge SchoolsToledo 99% 13th +1
Akron Preparatory SchoolAkron 83% 12th 0
Horizon Science Academy-DaytonDayton 80% 12th 0
East Branch Preparatory AcademydbaWright Preparatory AcademyCanton 65% 25th −1
Lorain Bilingual Preparatory AcademyLorain 70% 24th −2
Ann Jerkins-Harris Academy of ExcellenceToledo 96% 10th −2
Academy of Arts and TechnologyMarion 81% 10th −2
West Park Bilingual AcademyCleveland 80% 10th −2
Discovery AcademyToledo 80% 10th −2
Sheffield AcademySheffield Village 55% 41st −3
Pinnacle AcademyEuclid 72% 23rd −3
Horizon Science Academy Dayton DowntownDayton 85% 9th −3
Montgomery Preparatory AcademyDayton 84% 9th −3
Canton College Preparatory SchoolCanton 75% 22nd −4
Zenith Academy EastColumbus 62% 22nd −4
Madison Avenue School of ArtsToledo 99% 8th −4
Bella Academy of ExcellenceCleveland 98% 8th −4
Cleveland College Preparatory SchoolCleveland 98% 8th −4
Capital Collegiate Preparatory AcademyColumbus 80% 8th −4
Bridges Community Academy dba Bridges Preparatory AcademyTiffin 89% 7th −5
The Richland School of Academic ArtsMansfield 70% 20th −6
Noble Academy-ColumbusColumbus 60% 20th −6
Whitehall Preparatory and Fitness AcademyColumbus 61% 19th −7
University of Cleveland Preparatory SchoolCleveland 93% 5th −7
Constellation Schools: Puritas Community ElementaryCleveland 90% 5th −7
Eastland Preparatory AcademyColumbus 71% 18th −8
A+ Children's AcademyColumbus 65% 17th −9
Beacon AcademyCanton 90% 3rd −9
Heir Force Community SchoolLima 75% 16th −10
Edge LearningAkron 76% 16th −10
Lake Erie Preparatory SchoolCleveland 70% 16th −10
East AcademyCleveland 95% 2nd −10
A+ Arts AcademyColumbus 92% 2nd −10
Summit Academy Community School for Alternative Learn-CantonCanton 72% 15th −11
South Columbus Preparatory Academy at German VillageColumbus 72% 15th −11
Great Western AcademyColumbus 71% 15th −11
ReGeneration Bond HillCincinnati 72% 14th −12
Constellation Schools: Old Brooklyn Community ElementaryCleveland 70% 14th −12
Summit Academy Community School Alternative Learners-LorainLorain 91% 1st −12
Deca PrepDayton 40% 31st −13
Graham Elementary and Middle SchoolColumbus 62% 12th −14
Bridge Gate Community SchoolColumbus 54% 29th −15
Summit Academy Akron Elementary SchoolAkron 77% 11th −15
Riverside Community School Inc. dba Riverside AcademyCincinnati 72% 11th −15
Columbus Humanities Arts and Technology AcademyColumbus 60% 11th −15
Middletown Preparatory & Fitness AcademyMiddletown 56% 28th −16
Youngstown Academy of ExcellenceYoungstown 76% 10th −16
Case Preparatory AcademyAkron 77% 9th −17
ReGeneration Schools Avondale ElementaryCincinnati 57% 26th −18
Dayton SMART Elementary SchoolDayton 62% 8th −18
Horizon Science Academy-Cleveland Middle SchoolCleveland 50% 24th −20
Middlebury AcademyAkron 41% 24th −20
Summit Academy-YoungstownYoungstown 76% 5th −21
Euclid Preparatory SchoolEuclid 76% 5th −21
North Columbus Preparatory AcademyColumbus 73% 5th −21
East Preparatory AcademyCleveland 67% 5th −21
Constellation Schools: Madison Community ElementaryCleveland 68% 4th −22
Horizon Science Academy-CincinnatiCincinnati 77% 3rd −23
City Day Community SchoolDayton 75% 3rd −23
Constellation Schools: Eastside Arts AcademyCleveland 69% 3rd −23
Imagine Columbus Primary AcademyColumbus 69% 3rd −23
Constellation Schools: Stockyard Community ElementaryCleveland 66% 3rd −23
Kenmore Preparatory Academy dba Toledo Preparatory AcademyToledo 51% 19th −25
Summit Academy Community School-WarrenWarren 66% 1st −25
Kids Care ElementaryColumbus 59% 16th −28
Richard Allen AcademyHamilton 55% 15th −29
Horizon Science Academy-Denison Middle SchoolCleveland 56% 13th −31
Alliance Community Schools Inc. dba Dayton Leadership AcademyDayton 59% 11th −33
Richard Allen PreparatoryDayton 45% 10th −34
Fairfield Preparatory AcademyFairfield Township 35% 35th −36
Focus Learning Academy of Northern ColumbusColumbus 25% 33rd −38
Sullivant Avenue Community SchoolColumbus 50% 5th −39
Horizon Science Academy Elementary SchoolColumbus 32% 28th −43
Groveport Community SchoolGroveport 33% 24th −47
United Schools ColumbusColumbus 29% 19th −52
Constellation Schools: Elyria CommunityElyria 28% 18th −53
Orchard Park AcademyCleveland 33% 17th −54
Western Toledo Preparatory AcademyToledo 35% 16th −55
Summit Acdy Community School for Alternative Learners of MiddletownMiddletown 20% 13th −58
Legacy Academy of ExcellenceColumbus 30% 2nd −69

How this works

Why not just compare rankings?
Test scores track family income closely. If one kind of school serves more low-income students, it will rank lower even if it teaches just as well. So schools are first sorted into five groups by their share of low-income students (free or reduced-price lunch), and each charter school is compared only with traditional public schools in its own group.
Reading a row
The purple dot is the typical (median) charter school in that group, the gray dot the typical traditional public school; the number on the right is the gap between them in statewide percentile points. The gray bar shows where the middle half of traditional schools rank, so you can see how much schools vary.
The like-for-like number
The row gaps, averaged and weighted by how many charter schools each group holds. Groups with fewer than 3charter schools or 5 traditional schools are left out of it. It describes typical schools, not any one school; the dots show how widely charter schools differ from each other.
What's left out
Private schools, schools without a low-income figure, and schools too new or too small to rank. Rankings come from state test scores, one measure of a school. Read how SchoolDigger ranks schools.

Diagnostics