Summary
Carmel High School is a public high school in Carmel, Indiana, a suburban community north of Indianapolis, serving grades 9–12 in the Carmel Clay Schools district with 5,239 students — the largest enrollment in its nearby comparison set. It is one of Indiana's most consistently high-ranked schools: #4 of 415 statewide in 2025–2026 (99th percentile, 5 stars), while its district ranks #5 of 374. Since 2015–2016, the school has never ranked lower than #6 statewide and has earned 5 stars every year shown.
Academic results are far above nearby comprehensive high schools and the state. Its 2024–25 graduation rate is 99.1%, compared with 98.2% at Westfield High School, 94.4% at North Central High School, 93.0% at Lawrence North High School, and 89.7% statewide. In 2025–26, 83.1% of students were proficient in SAT ERW (state: 51.9%; Westfield: 76.15%) and 63.82% in SAT Math — more than double the state's 25.6% and well above Westfield's 53.1%, North Central's 24.89%, and Lawrence North's 15.12%. Biology ILEARN proficiency is 78.42%, up sharply from 60.63% in 2022–23. The school also ranks in the top 5% statewide for its effectiveness with nearly every measured student subgroup, including students in special education, English language learners, and students from low-income families. It achieves this with per-student spending of $11,447 — similar to Westfield and Lawrence North, and lower than North Central's $13,989 — and a student-teacher ratio of 16.7.
Two watch points stand out. Chronic absenteeism is 11.5%, better than the state's 16.7% but higher than Westfield's 9.9% and nearly double the district's 6.4%. SAT Math proficiency also remains below its 2022–23 peak of 70.13%, though it is still strong. Nearby alternative and charter schools such as Options Indiana, Options Noblesville, Indiana Agriculture and Technology, and Options Westfield serve different missions and populations and are not direct peers.
Thank you for your feedback!