Summary
Cherry Tree Elementary School is a PK–5 school in Carmel, Indiana, serving 711 students as part of Carmel Clay Schools, a district ranked 5th of 374 in Indiana. Cherry Tree itself is consistently elite: in 2025–2026 it ranked 37th of 1,015 Indiana elementary schools (96th percentile, 5 stars), and it has earned 5 stars in every year provided, staying in roughly the top 3–5% of elementary schools statewide.
Math and science are the school's relative strengths. On 2025–2026 ILEARN tests, 73.54% of Cherry Tree students were proficient in math, above the Carmel Clay average of 71.81% and second among same-district peers only to Prairie Trace (82.91%). Science (70.09%) is essentially tied with Prairie Trace for the top same-district result. ELA is the relative gap at 66.85%, below the district's 70.76% and behind Prairie Trace, New Britton, and Harrison Parkway, though still far above statewide proficiency of roughly 41–42%. By grade, 3rd grade math is the strongest result (78.57% versus the district's 77.4%), while 5th grade ELA, math, and social studies all sit below district averages — a possible focus area.
Beyond test scores, Cherry Tree's chronic absenteeism rate is 5.4%, better than the district (6.4%) and the state (16.7%), though higher than several Carmel Clay peers such as Prairie Trace (1.9%) and Mohawk Trails (2.9%). Its free/reduced lunch rate is 12.94%, among the lowest in the comparison group, and per-student spending is $11,794, less than most same-district peers. Its student-teacher ratio of 15.6 is the highest among same-district Carmel peers, yet the school still posts top-tier results. Overall, Cherry Tree is a consistently high-performing, top-5% school whose main peer-relative challenge is matching Prairie Trace in ELA and attendance.
Thank you for your feedback!