School InsightsBeta · Florida

Charter vs. traditional public schools, like for like

Charter schools often serve different students than the public school down the street, so comparing their rankings straight up misleads. Here each Florida charter high school is set only against traditional public schools serving a similar share of low-income students.

At first glance

Charter53rd
Traditional51st

Typical school's statewide percentile. On raw rankings, the typical charter school and the typical traditional school rank about the same. But they serve different students, so that's not a fair fight.

Like for like

−6 points

Compared with traditional public schools serving similar students, charter schools rank 6 percentile points lower.

Side by side, among schools serving similar students

It depends on the neighborhood: charter schools trail where under 20% of students are low-income (−55) and lead where 80% or more are (+28).

  • Typical charter school
  • Typical traditional public school
  • Middle half of traditional schools
  • Each charter school
Under 20%40 charter · 27 traditional
89th34th
−55 charter
20–39%41 charter · 89 traditional
67th80th
+13 charter
40–59%43 charter · 121 traditional
43rd47th
+4 charter
60–79%27 charter · 57 traditional
22nd32nd
+10 charter
80% or more8 charter · 14 traditional
12th40th
+28 charter

Statewide percentile in the 2025-26 rankings, all students. Point at a dot to see the school; click it to keep its card open.

Not shown: virtual schools (45 ranked, but only 5 report a low-income figure). A fair comparison needs at least 10 high schools of a type with a low-income figure.

Charter schools that do best for the students they serve

Ranked by how far each school sits above the typical traditional public school serving a similar share of low-income students.

SchoolLow-incomeStatewidevs. similar traditional
Somerset Academy Charter High SchoolHomestead 83% 91st +79
Mater Performing Arts & Entertainment AcademyHialeah Gardens 78% 95th +73
International Studies Charter High SchoolMiami 62% 90th +68
Miami Technical At Mater Innovation AcademyMiami 73% 89th +67
Mater Academy Bay High SchoolCutler Bay 60% 89th +67
Mater Brickell Academy HighMiami 66% 85th +63
City Of Hialeah Educational AcademyHialeah 82% 71st +59
State College Of Florida Collegiate SchoolBradenton 46% 94th +51
Mater Lakes Collegiate Academy High SchoolMiami 66% 71st +49
Somerset College Preparatory AcademyPort Saint Lucie 48% 88th +45
Every charter school, in numbers (159)
SchoolLow-incomeStatewidevs. similar traditional
Somerset Academy Charter High SchoolHomestead 83% 91st +79
Mater Performing Arts & Entertainment AcademyHialeah Gardens 78% 95th +73
International Studies Charter High SchoolMiami 62% 90th +68
Miami Technical At Mater Innovation AcademyMiami 73% 89th +67
Mater Academy Bay High SchoolCutler Bay 60% 89th +67
Mater Brickell Academy HighMiami 66% 85th +63
City Of Hialeah Educational AcademyHialeah 82% 71st +59
State College Of Florida Collegiate SchoolBradenton 46% 94th +51
Mater Lakes Collegiate Academy High SchoolMiami 66% 71st +49
Somerset College Preparatory AcademyPort Saint Lucie 48% 88th +45
Mater Academy Charter High SchoolHialeah Gardens 78% 66th +44
Santa Fe College Academy Of Science And TechnologyGainesville 40% 86th +43
Mater Academy Lakes High SchoolHialeah 70% 65th +43
River City Science AcademyJacksonville 55% 85th +42
Pinecrest Preparatory Academy Charter High SchoolMiami 57% 84th +41
Charter High School Of The Americas (Florida City Campus)Florida City 56% 84th +41
Youth County-Op Preparatory High SchoolHialeah 72% 63rd +41
Pinecrest Glades Preparatory Academy Middle High SchoolMiami 49% 82nd +39
Palm Bay Preparatory Academy 6-12Panama City 55% 81st +38
Lake Wales Senior High SchoolLake Wales 69% 60th +38
New Dimensions High SchoolKissimmee 48% 79th +36
Riverview Academy High SchoolCoral Springs 50% 76th +33
Archimedean Upper ConservatoryMiami 32% 99th +32
St. Petersburg Collegiate High School North PinellasTarpon Springs 25% 99th +32
Collegiate High School At Northwest Florida State CollegeNiceville 24% 98th +31
Doral Performing Arts & Entertainment AcademyDoral 24% 98th +31
South Technical AcademyBoynton Beach 52% 74th +31
Somerset Academy Charter High School (South Homestead)Homestead 83% 43rd +31
Somerset Preparatory Academy High School HomesteadHomestead 81% 42nd +30
St. Petersburg Collegiate Stem High SchoolSaint Petersburg 30% 96th +29
Doral Academy Charter High SchoolDoral 27% 96th +29
Bridgeprep Academy Of Riverview Middle-HighRiverview 41% 72nd +29
Imater Preparatory Academy High SchoolHialeah 74% 51st +29
Mater Academy Narcoossee High SchoolOrlando 47% 71st +28
Duval Charter High School At BaymeadowsJacksonville 47% 71st +28
G-Star School Of The ArtsWest Palm Beach 40% 71st +28
Somerset Preparatory Academy Charter High At North LauderdaNorth Lauderdale 93% 38th +26
Don Soffer Aventura Charter High SchoolAventura 23% 92nd +25
Somerset College Preparatory Academy South High SchoolMiami 78% 46th +24
Sports Leadership Arts Management Charter High SchoolMiami 64% 46th +24
Manatee School For The ArtsPalmetto 40% 66th +23
McKeel Academy Of TechnologyLakeland 36% 89th +22
North Bay Haven Career AcademyPanama City 28% 88th +21
City/Pembroke Pines Charter High SchoolPembroke Pines 28% 88th +21
Somerset Arts ConservatoryPembroke Pines 28% 88th +21
Pinecrest Lakes Middle/High AcademyClermont 23% 88th +21
Mater Biscayne Academy North Miami High SchoolMiami 38% 87th +20
State College Of Fla Collegiate School-VeniceVenice 33% 87th +20
Inlet Grove Community High SchoolRiviera Beach 59% 61st +18
International Studies Academy High SchoolMiami 59% 61st +18
Indian River Charter High SchoolVero Beach 30% 84th +17
Everglades Preparatory Academy High SchoolHomestead 51% 60th +17
Cornerstone Charter Academy HighBelle Isle 35% 83rd +16
Marco Island AcademyMarco Island 26% 82nd +15
Oasis Charter High SchoolCape Coral 22% 82nd +15
Pinecrest Academy Wesley Chapel High SchoolWesley Chapel 37% 81st +14
Academy Of Environmental ScienceCrystal River 34% 80th +13
Doctors Charter School Of Miami ShoresMiami Shores 24% 80th +13
Palm Beach Maritime Academy SecondaryLantana 53% 56th +13
St. Petersburg Collegiate High SchoolSt Petersburg 10% 99th +10
Keys Gate Charter High SchoolHomestead 47% 53rd +10
Mater Brighton Lakes Academy Preparatory HighKissimmee 78% 32nd +10
The Collegiate School At Fsu PcPanama City 12% 98th +9
Florida Southwestern Collegiate High SchoolFort Myers 12% 97th +8
Somerset Academy Charter HighPembroke Pines 34% 75th +8
Seaside Neighborhood SchoolSanta Rosa Beach 3% 96th +7
Clark Advanced Learning CenterStuart 19% 96th +7
Pensacola State College Charter AcademyPensacola 9% 95th +6
Florida Southwestern Collegiate High SchoolPunta Gorda 8% 94th +5
San Jose Early College At CecilJacksonville 49% 47th +4
Dr Kiran C Patel High SchoolTampa 7% 92nd +3
Bell Creek AcademyRiverview 8% 92nd +3
Orlando Science Middle High CharterOrlando 19% 92nd +3
Somerset Academy Canyons High SchoolBoynton Beach 31% 70th +3
Discovery High SchoolLake Alfred 64% 25th +3
Downtown Doral Charter Upper SchoolDoral 18% 91st +2
Somerset Academy Wellington High SchoolWellington 38% 69th +2
Sarasota Military AcademySarasota 53% 45th +2
Miami Arts Charter SchoolMiami 1% 90th +1
Miami Community Charter High SchoolFlorida City 78% 23rd +1
Amikids Maritime AcademyPanama City 23% 67th 0
Everglades Preparatory AcademyPahokee 86% 12th 0
Walton Academy Inc.Defuniak Springs 81% 11th −1
Charter High School Of The AmericasMiami 36% 65th −2
Indiantown High SchoolIndiantown 52% 41st −2
The Seed School Of MiamiMiami 74% 19th −3
Victory Charter SchoolKissimmee 61% 19th −3
Pinecrest North Preparatory High SchoolMiami 16% 85th −4
Coral Springs Charter SchoolCoral Springs 3% 84th −5
Destin High SchoolDestin 21% 60th −7
Somerset Academy Charter High School Miramar CampusMiramar 50% 35th −8
Elevation High SchoolSanford 67% 14th −8
Somerset Island PrepKey West 36% 58th −9
Slam Academy High School Palm BeachWest Palm Beach 55% 33rd −10
The College Of The Florida Keys AcademyKey West 11% 78th −11
Brooks Debartolo Collegiate High SchoolTampa 11% 78th −11
Duval Mycroschool IncJacksonville 87% 1st −11
Tallahassee Collegiate AcademyTallahassee 4% 77th −12
Palm Glades Preparatory High SchoolMiami 54% 31st −12
Global Leadership Academy High SchoolJacksonville 49% 30th −13
North Central Florida Public Charter SchoolGainesville 75% 9th −13
Slam BocaMiami 29% 53rd −14
Micanopy AcademyMicanopy 46% 28th −15
Quantum High SchoolBoynton Beach 66% 6th −16
Four Corners Upper SchoolDavenport 35% 50th −17
New Beginnings High SchoolWinter Haven 77% 5th −17
Biscayne Mycroschool IncJacksonville 62% 5th −17
Worthington High SchoolWest Palm Beach 60% 4th −18
Sports Leadership And Management Academy (Tampa)Tampa 50% 23rd −20
Pinellas Mycroschool Of Integrated Academics And TechnologiSt Petersburg 71% 2nd −20
Richard Milburn AcademyDaytona Beach 70% 2nd −20
Tradition Preparatory High SchoolFort Lauderdale 37% 46th −21
Winthrop College Prep AcademyFort Lauderdale 26% 46th −21
Palm Beach Preparatory Charter AcademyPalm Springs 62% 1st −22
Avant Garde Academy Of BrowardHollywood 37% 44th −23
Franklin Academy Pembroke Pines High SchoolPembroke Pines 3% 65th −24
Ocali Charter High SchoolOcala 55% 18th −25
Bridgeprep Academy Of Village Green Middle High SchoolMiami 37% 41st −26
North Nicholas High SchoolCape Coral 43% 13th −30
Bradenton Bay High SchoolBradenton 53% 12th −31
Enterprise Charter High SchoolClearwater 58% 11th −32
Siatech Mycroschool Inc.Gainesville 56% 11th −32
Palm Acres Charter High SchoolLehigh Acres 59% 10th −33
Central High SchoolPanama City 40% 10th −33
Coronado High SchoolFort Myers 56% 9th −34
Northern Palms Charter High SchoolNorth Fort Myers 44% 7th −36
Seminole Heights Charter High SchoolTampa 41% 7th −36
Island Park High SchoolFort Myers 45% 6th −37
Victory Charter School Tampa 6-12Riverview 12% 50th −39
Donna J. Beasley Technical AcademyLehigh Acres 44% 4th −39
Academir Preparatory High SchoolMiami 30% 27th −40
Sports Leadership Arts Management Charter High School (NortNorth Miami Beach 37% 26th −41
Pivot Charter SchoolRiverview 35% 25th −42
Main Street High SchoolKissimmee 57% 1st −43
Central Florida Leadership Academy CharterOrlando 39% 22nd −45
James Madison Preparatory High SchoolMadison 2% 38th −51
Somerset Academy Key Charter High SchoolMiami 2% 30th −59
Ascend Career AcademyMargate 7% 28th −61
Lone Star Mycroschool IncJacksonville 39% 3rd −64
West University Charter HighTampa 30% 3rd −64
International School Of BrowardHollywood 7% 24th −65
Ucp Transitional Learning Academy CharterOrlando 38% 2nd −65
Colegiate Preparatory AcademyMiami 5% 19th −70
Andrews High SchoolPompano Beach 6% 12th −77
Chambers High SchoolHomestead 5% 11th −78
Suned High Of North BrowardMargate 8% 10th −79
Suned High Of South BrowardFort Lauderdale 17% 10th −79
Kendall Greens High SchoolMiami 7% 8th −81
Doral Park High SchoolDoral 12% 7th −82
North Park High SchoolOpa Locka 4% 6th −83
Sandra Marie Curtis High SchoolFort Lauderdale 6% 6th −83
Alee Academy Charter SchoolEustis 17% 6th −83
Stellar Leadership AcademyMiami 12% 5th −84
C. G. Bethel High SchoolNorth Miami Beach 7% 4th −85
Academic Solutions AcademyCoral Springs 4% 3rd −86
North Gardens High SchoolMiami Gardens 6% 2nd −87
Green Springs High SchoolMiami 4% 1st −88
Sunfire High SchoolOakland Park 7% 1st −88
Academic Solutions Academy ACoral Springs 8% 1st −89

How this works

Why not just compare rankings?
Test scores track family income closely. If one kind of school serves more low-income students, it will rank lower even if it teaches just as well. So schools are first sorted into five groups by their share of low-income students (free or reduced-price lunch), and each charter school is compared only with traditional public schools in its own group.
Reading a row
The purple dot is the typical (median) charter school in that group, the gray dot the typical traditional public school; the number on the right is the gap between them in statewide percentile points. The gray bar shows where the middle half of traditional schools rank, so you can see how much schools vary.
The like-for-like number
The row gaps, averaged and weighted by how many charter schools each group holds. Groups with fewer than 3charter schools or 5 traditional schools are left out of it. It describes typical schools, not any one school; the dots show how widely charter schools differ from each other.
What's left out
Private schools, schools without a low-income figure, and schools too new or too small to rank. Rankings come from state test scores, one measure of a school. Read how SchoolDigger ranks schools.

Diagnostics