Summary:
Midfield City is a small, high-poverty Alabama school district serving about 992 students across three schools: Midfield Elementary School (PK-4), Rutledge School (grades 5-8), and Midfield High School (grades 9-12). All three schools rank in the bottom 12% of Alabama schools, with the district overall sitting at the 4th percentile statewide.
Among the three, Rutledge School is the clear standout. It has the district’s best attendance—just 2.7% chronic absenteeism versus the 12% state average—and posts the strongest single subject score in the district: 43.4% English proficiency for 5th graders. It also showed the most dramatic year-over-year improvement, with 6th grade English jumping from 19.05% to 33.85%. Midfield Elementary School is the most consistent improver, highlighted by a stunning 21-point leap in 4th grade science proficiency (from 13.11% to 34.38%) and solid 4th grade English scores at 35.94%. Midfield High School is the district’s biggest challenge: only 1.54% of 11th graders are proficient in math, and English proficiency sits at just 4.84%. Its graduation rate of 86.2% trails the state’s 91.5%, and the disconnect between passing students and their near-zero test scores raises serious concerns about college and career readiness.
A troubling pattern emerges in math: proficiency collapses as students advance. At Rutledge, 5th grade math proficiency is 16.98%, dropping to 2.99% by 8th grade, and then to 1.54% in high school. English is a relative strength across all grades, suggesting literacy instruction is a foundation to build on. Attendance is not the problem—students show up. The district also spends a substantial $11,182–$13,639 per student, yet results remain in the bottom 10% statewide, indicating resources aren’t translating into outcomes. The 2025-2026 data does show small gains nearly everywhere, offering a faint silver lining that the district may be starting to turn a corner, though the high school’s stagnation remains deeply concerning.
Thank you for your feedback!