Summary
Upper Scioto Valley High School in McGuffey, Ohio, is a small public high school serving grades 9–12 with 159 students, part of the Upper Scioto Valley Local district in a very high-poverty community (98% free/reduced lunch in 2023–2024). The school ranked 461st of 795 Ohio high schools in 2025–2026 (42nd percentile, 2 stars), while the district ranked 517th of 773 (33rd percentile, 2 stars). It has improved from 1-star, 23rd–27th percentile ratings in 2015–2019 to 2-star, 40s percentile ratings, but remains in the lower-middle of Ohio schools.
Science and English are relative strengths. Biology proficiency was 81.6% versus the state’s 67%, near the top of nearby schools behind Ada High School (85.5%), Bath High School (84.7%), and Bluffton High School (83.0%). English II was 68.3% versus the state’s 62.7%, mid-pack locally. Math is the clearest weakness: Geometry was 19.5% versus the state’s 43.3%, far below every nearby comprehensive high school except Perry High School (18.0%). Algebra I was 59.3% versus the state’s 61.6%, 8th of 9 nearby. Geometry has been far below state for four years (30% in 2024–2025, 15% in 2023–2024, 24.1% in 2022–2023). Nearby Ada High School, Bluffton High School, Bath High School, and Hardin Northern High School consistently outperform the school, while Kenton High School is lower.
Chronic absenteeism improved dramatically from 38.9% in 2021–2022 to 19.2% in 2025–2026, but it remains above the district rate of 16.1% and middle-to-upper among nearby schools. The graduation rate was a solid 96.6% in 2025–2026. Low-socioeconomic-status students are a relative strength: the school ranked in the 54th percentile (3 stars) in 2025–2026 and 67th percentile (3 stars) in 2024–2025, above its overall rank. Gifted and talented students are a major weakness, ranking in the 6th percentile (0 stars) in both 2024–2025 and 2023–2024. With only 159 students, single-year swings should be read cautiously, but the multi-year math weakness is a clear pattern. High poverty is a significant context, yet nearby Ada High School also serves a high-poverty population and achieves at a much higher level, suggesting poverty alone does not explain the gaps.
Thank you for your feedback!