Summary
McKinley High School is a grades 9–12 school serving 530 students in Niles, Ohio, a Youngstown-area community in the Mahoning Valley, and it is part of the Niles City district. In 2025–26 it ranked 601 of 795 Ohio high schools (24th percentile, 1 star), down sharply from 514 of 855 (40th percentile, 2 stars) in 2024–25. The district as a whole ranks 509 of 773 (34th percentile, 2 stars), so the school is currently performing below its own district. Over the past decade, McKinley has generally sat between the 29th and 44th percentile, peaking at the 50th percentile in 2016–17, making this the lowest result in the available history.
Two non-test measures stand out. McKinley's graduation rate is 89.8%, a bit under the district's 89.9% and below nearly every nearby traditional high school: Mineral Ridge High School at 100%, McDonald High School at 96.8%, Howland High School at 96.5%, Liberty High School at 94.9%, Girard Senior High School at 94.9%, Lordstown High School at 94.6%, and Warren G Harding High School at 92.9%. Chronic absenteeism is the bigger issue: 48.5% of students, versus 35.9% district-wide and far above McDonald (21.9%), Lordstown (23.9%), Mathews (23.9%), Mineral Ridge (24.5%), Howland (34.0%), and Girard (37.4%). Only Warren Harding (58.3%) and River Gate (93.9%) are higher. It has improved from 57.8% in 2021–22, but remains high.
Results by subject are uneven. Algebra I is a strength at 70.5% proficient, above the state's 61.6%, and English II is essentially at state level (63.0% vs 62.7%). Biology is close (61.8% vs 67.0%). Geometry is a severe weakness at 24.0% versus 43.3% statewide, and social studies is weak across the board: American Government 56.3% vs 71.6%, and American History 54.1% vs 73.2%. On subgroup effectiveness, McKinley earned 1 star for female, male, White, multiracial, and gifted students, and 2 stars for African American students, special education students, and low-income students; the gifted group fell from the 66th percentile two years earlier to the 20th. Overall, McKinley trails Mathews High School and the other higher-ranked nearby districts, sits close to Liberty, and remains above Warren Harding and the area's alternative and charter schools, including Summit Academy Alternative LearnersWarren Middle & Secondary.
Thank you for your feedback!