Summary
Shutesbury Elementary is a small public PK–6 school in Shutesbury, MA, a rural town in western Massachusetts near Amherst, serving about 125 students. It has climbed steadily in state rankings, from 444th of 938 schools (53rd percentile) in 2016–17 to 145th of 899 schools (84th percentile, 4 stars) in 2025–26, placing it among the top ~16% of Massachusetts elementary schools. The Shutesbury district ranks 47th of 351 districts (87th percentile, 4 stars).
Test scores are the school's clearest strength. In 2025–26, 64.41% of students met proficiency in ELA (state: 40.03%), 61.02% in math (state: 41.11%), and 90.91% in science (state: 40.98%). Those rates lead every nearby school, including Pelham Elementary, Leverett Elementary, and Whately Elementary. Science, tested in grade 5, has been consistently far above state levels. Math has improved markedly, from 43.28% in 2022–23 to 61.02% now. One caution: 5th-grade math was 27.27%, below the state's 39.5%, while that same grade level scored 90.91% in science — likely small-cohort volatility in a school this size.
Class sizes are very small: a 6.8 student-teacher ratio in 2024–25, lower than most neighbors except Erving Elementary (6.1). Spending was $25,048 per student in 2020–21 — mid-to-high locally but below Erving ($41,150) and the larger Amherst schools Crocker Farm Elementary, Wildwood Elementary, and Fort River Elementary, which post lower proficiency. Pelham is the closest competitor at 189th (79th percentile, 4 stars) but has a 10.6 ratio and lower spending of $21,032 per student. Free/reduced-price lunch data were unavailable, so socioeconomic context cannot be assessed.
Thank you for your feedback!