Summary
Hatherly Elementary is a K–5 school in Scituate, MA, serving 263 students as part of the Scituate district. In 2025–26, it ranked 168th of 899 Massachusetts schools (81st percentile, 4 stars), while the district ranked 56th of 351 (84th percentile, 4 stars). The school has historically been strong, with 5-star peaks in 2016–17 and 2018–19, but recent years have mostly been in the 80s percentile. It is the smallest elementary in the district: Jenkins Elementary School (341), Cushing Elementary (352), and Wampatuck Elementary (424). Its student–teacher ratio was 11.4 in 2024–25, and per-student spending was $19,437 in 2020–21. Free/reduced-price lunch data are suppressed, so economic comparisons are not available.
In 2025–26, it scored above both district and state in all three MCAS subjects: ELA 58.93 vs. district 57.35 and state 40.03; math 62.83 vs. 60.84 and 41.11; science 63.89 vs. 60.24 and 40.98. Within the district, it was third of four in ELA and math but second in science. Grade-level results show a split: third grade ELA and math were below district and lowest among same-district peers, though still above state, while fourth-grade math was 80.00 and fifth-grade science was 63.89, both strong. Compared with nearby schools, Hingham’s South Elementary and East Elementary School, Cohasset’s Deer Hill, and Norwell’s Grace Farrar Cole often outperformed it in 2025–26, so it is strong locally but not top-tier across the broader area.
One notable concern is special education effectiveness: the school’s special education subgroup ranked 54th percentile (3 stars) in 2024–25 and 49th percentile (2 stars) in 2023–24, compared with overall ranks of 87th and 80th percentile. Gender results are balanced, with female students at 82nd percentile and male students at 80th in 2025–26. Because enrollment is small, grade-level percentages can shift with a few students. High spending and low student–teacher ratios have not produced consistent top-of-peer-group results. Overall, the school is a solidly above-average school with strengths in science and fourth-grade math, plus challenges in third grade and special education effectiveness.
Thank you for your feedback!