Summary
Indian Brook is a K–5 elementary school at 1181 State Rd in Plymouth, MA, serving 520 students as part of the Plymouth district, which is ranked 182 of 351 districts statewide. In 2025–2026, Indian Brook ranks 487 of 899 schools, placing it in the 46th percentile with 2 stars. On 2025–2026 MCAS Next Generation tests, 41.37% of students met expectations in ELA (above the state's 40.03% but below the district's 44.8%), 37.2% in math, and 36.36% in science, which is below both district and state. Its 2024–2025 student–teacher ratio is 11.9, and its 2020–2021 per-student spending is $18,010.
Among the eight Plymouth K–5 elementary schools compared here, Indian Brook ranks 7th of 8, ahead of only Hedge and roughly tied with South Elementary. Manomet Elementary, just 2.28 miles away, is the strongest local contrast: a 77th-percentile, 4-star school that outperforms Indian Brook by 16.15 points in ELA, 16.78 points in math, and 25.8 points in science. Science is Indian Brook's sharpest local weakness — its 36.36% is the lowest among Plymouth peers, well behind West Elementary (65.45%), Federal Furnace School (63.33%), and Manomet (62.16%). Cold Spring and Nathaniel Morton Elementary also rank higher.
Indian Brook has slipped over recent years, from the 68th percentile in 2020–2021 and 54th percentile in 2024–2025 to 46th percentile in 2025–2026, dropping from 3 stars to 2 stars. Math fell 7.68 points and science 8.22 points year over year, steeper than district declines. Grade-level results point to grade 3 math (33.73%) and grade 5 science (36.36%) as the main pressure points, while grade 4 is comparatively solid. Subgroup results are uneven: low-income students rank at the 59th percentile, above the school overall, while special education students rank at the 36th. Notably, Indian Brook still outperforms Bourne Intermediate School (24th percentile, 1 star).
Thank you for your feedback!