Summary:
ZIP code 07866 has nine schools serving 4,953 students across three elementary, two middle and four high schools in four districts. In 2025–2026, elementary results averaged above state levels in ELA and math, high-school averages were notably higher in several reported measures, and middle-school math averaged below the state. The most important takeaway is that results vary sharply by school, grade and subject—not all schools in the area perform alike.
Stony Brook Elementary is the clearest elementary standout: it beat state results in all six reported grade 3–5 ELA and math measures, including fourth-grade math at 90% versus 47%, a 43-point advantage. Results were less consistent at Katharine D. Malone Elementary; its fifth-grade science was 18%, compared with 46% at Stony Brook and 27% statewide. Among high schools, Academy for Mathematics Science and Engineering reached 100% in ninth-grade ELA and 11th-grade science and ranked No. 1 of 434 New Jersey high schools in SchoolDigger’s 2025–2026 ranking. But results are not uniformly high: Morris Knolls and Morris Hills had 6.7% and 6.1% proficiency, respectively, in 10th-grade Algebra I, versus 19.5% statewide.
Year-to-year results show both gains and declines, rather than a clear overall upward trend. Stony Brook’s ELA was broadly steady, while its fourth-grade math rose 17 points; at Malone, fifth-grade ELA and math fell 34 and 35 points, even as fourth-grade results improved. SchoolDigger also ranked Academy for Performing Arts 39 of 434 high schools and Stony Brook 217 of 1,331 elementary schools. As context, student-teacher ratios were 9.2 at Stony Brook and 12.5 at Lincoln Elementary; free/reduced lunch eligible shares in sy 2024–2025 ranged from 7% at Stony Brook to 32% at Thomas Jefferson Middle among schools with that measure.
Thank you for your feedback!