Summary
Knox Trail Middle School is a grades 5–8 school at 73 Ash Street in Spencer, Massachusetts, serving 415 students in the small-town Spencer-E Brookfield district. It sits in the lowest performance tier statewide: 374th of 478 middle schools in 2025-26 (22nd percentile, 1 star), while its district ranks 279th of 351 (21st percentile, 1 star). Knox Trail has earned one star in each of the last four years, with its percentile drifting from 26 to 25 to 23 to 22. Because its percentile is essentially the same as its district's, it is representative of Spencer-E Brookfield rather than an outlier within it.
In 2025-26, proficiency was roughly half the state level in every tested subject: 21.45% in English language arts (state 40.03%), 18.60% in math (state 41.11%), 20.11% in science (state 40.98%), and 21.50% in 8th-grade civics (state 39.77%). The school trails its own district in ELA, math, and science, and beats it only in civics. Against nearby schools it sits near the bottom of the local cluster — well behind Mountview Middle and Central Tree Middle in the Wachusett district, and behind Auburn Middle and Tantasqua Regional Junior High. The closest small-town peers, Leicester Middle and Charlton Middle, outperform Knox Trail in all four subjects by 3 to 17 points, and Oxford Middle more than doubles its math proficiency.
The pattern varies sharply by grade. Fifth grade — the school's entry point — is the weak spot, with 10.96% proficient in ELA and 8.22% in math against state rates near 38–40%, and it trails the 5th grades at Leicester and Charlton on the same exams. Because grade 5 is included, the all-grades averages are pulled down relative to schools that start at grade 6. Seventh grade is the relative bright spot, and civics is the school's one genuine strength — the only subject that improved year over year and the only one where it beats the district. Science is the clear decline, down about 9.5 points from its 2023-24 peak. Spending and staffing do not explain the local gap: Knox Trail spent $15,556 per student in 2020-21, more than Mountview and Auburn, while producing a fraction of their proficiency.
Thank you for your feedback!