Summary:
Zip code 41501 has 11 schools—five elementary schools and six high schools—with grade spans ranging from prekindergarten through grade 12 and a combined enrollment of 5,192. The schools vary widely in size and in their reported results. The most important takeaway for families is that school performance differs substantially by grade and subject, so an area-wide label would hide important differences.
Millard School and Pikeville High School are the clearest standouts: Millard leads elementary results in several grades and subjects, while Pikeville High leads the reported grade-10 and grade-11 comparisons and has a 100% graduation rate, versus 94% statewide. SchoolDigger ranks Millard 8th of 684 schools and Pikeville High 1st of 262. Results at other schools can be much lower: grade-3 math ranges from 35% at Mullins Elementary School to 88% at Valley Elementary School, while grade-5 reading ranges from 44% at Mullins to 94% at Millard. Among high schools, grade-11 science ranges from 14% at Pike County Central High School to 52% at Pikeville High. Valley also has strikingly mixed results, from 88% in grade-3 math to 30% in grade-8 math.
Recent elementary results improved relative to state benchmarks overall, but not at every school: across matched math and reading results, the average school score gained about 4 percentage points relative to the state, with average changes ranging from +11 points at Millard and +7 at Johns Creek Elementary School to −1 at Valley and −2 at Pikeville Elementary School. SchoolDigger’s three-year percentile history also shows different paths: Millard rose from 92 to 99, Pikeville High from 98 to 100, while Pikeville Elementary fell from 93 to 88. Among the elementary schools, the 2024–2025 free/reduced lunch eligible share ranges from 36% at Pikeville Elementary to 80% at Johns Creek; student-teacher ratios range from 13.6 at Johns Creek to 17.9 at Valley. These figures offer context, but do not explain school results.
Thank you for your feedback!