Summary:
Pike County has 20 schools—11 elementary, one middle and eight high schools—serving students from elementary through high school, with test results varying considerably between schools and grades. In 2025–2026, fifth-grade social studies ranged from 30% at Kimper Elementary School to 87% at Elkhorn City Elementary School, a 57-point gap; eighth-grade math ranged from 16% at Phelps High School to 69% at Millard School, a 53-point gap. The most important finding for families is that results depend heavily on the school, grade and subject—not on one countywide picture of school performance.
Millard School is the broadest test-score standout: it led reported results in grades 6–8 math (76%, 68% and 69%) and grades 5–7 reading (94%, 91% and 88%), with its fifth-grade reading score 43 points above the state. Other schools led in particular areas: Elkhorn City Elementary School scored 82% in fifth-grade math and 87% in fifth-grade social studies, while Valley Elementary School led third-grade math at 88% and fourth-grade reading at 90%. At the lower end of selected results, Kimper Elementary School scored 30% in fifth-grade social studies and editing and mechanics, below state results of 38% and 48%. Phelps High School had low eighth-grade math and reading scores—16% and 22%—but a 100% graduation rate, compared with 94% statewide.
Recent results show improvement in some places and declines in others. Across four comprehensive high schools’ 24 comparable score pairs, average proficiency rose 3 points from 2024–2025 to 2025–2026, and the average gap versus state results improved by about 2 points; writing fell 3 points while the state result rose 2. SchoolDigger’s percentile rankings also rose for Millard School (92 to 99 from 2023–2024 to 2025–2026) and Elkhorn City Elementary School (67 to 92), but fell for Kimper Elementary School (71 to 32). As context, 2024–2025 free/reduced lunch eligible figures were 79% at Millard, 81% at Elkhorn City and 85% at Phelps Elementary School; these measures do not neatly distinguish schools by results. School-level scores are not available for every test.
Thank you for your feedback!