Summary
Coolspring Elementary School is a K–6 neighborhood school serving 249 students in Michigan City, IN, part of Michigan City Area Schools — a district ranked 277th of 374 Indiana districts (26th percentile, 1 star). Coolspring ranks slightly above that baseline: 707th of 1,015 Indiana elementary schools (30th percentile, 2 stars) in 2025–2026, up from 737th. It is the smallest of eight MCAS elementaries in this comparison set (peers run 296–416 students), so with 30–40 students per grade, single-grade results swing widely. About 66.27% of students qualify for free or reduced lunch.
That volatility is the school's defining trait. In 2025–2026, 3rd grade posted just 5.13% proficiency in ELA and 7.69% in math, while 5th grade reached 55.56% and 58.33% — a roughly 50-point spread, and 5th grade beats both the district and the state. Science is the one subject where Coolspring trails its own district (18.57% vs. 24.74%), with 4th grade science at 14.71% against the district's 26.23%. Attendance has improved notably: chronic absenteeism fell from 40.0% in 2021–22 to 21.9% in 2024–25, better than the district's 28.9%, though still above the state's 16.7%.
High spending has not yet produced high results. Coolspring's $15,785 per student is the third-highest among eleven compared schools, yet outcomes remain in the bottom third statewide. Knapp Elementary School serves a nearly identical poverty rate (66.09% vs. 66.27%), spends $1,540 less per student, and posts much stronger results: 36.11% ELA, 44.44% math, 44.25% science, ranking 515th. Nearby out-of-district schools show similar patterns — Renaissance Academy Charter School and F Willard Crichfield Elementary post 46–70% proficiency with far lower absenteeism, though poverty rates there are much lower (27% and 22%). Bottom line: modest recovery, strong grades 5–6, a struggling 3rd grade, and a clear science gap.
Thank you for your feedback!