Summary:
ZIP code 46391 is served by just two schools — Westville Elementary School (PK–6, 499 students) and Westville High School (grades 7–12, 409 students) — both part of MSD of New Durham Township and both at 207 E Valparaiso St in Westville. There is no separate middle school, so grades 7 and 8 are included in the high school's record and results.
Performance at the two schools looks very different. Westville High is the academic standout, ranked 117 of 415 (72nd percentile, 4 stars) in 2025–2026 after a 5-star peak the year before. Its ELA and SAT reading results beat the state (57.58 vs. 51.9), and Biology End of Course reached 59.42. Math is its weak spot: SAT Math is 16.67 against a state 25.6, and 7th and 8th grade math are below state as well. Westville Elementary ranks 635 of 1015 (37th percentile, 2 stars), and in 2025–2026 every shown grade-level ILEARN result was below state; its math fell from 40.66% to 34.75% and science dropped 11.59 points. The district sits at the 61st percentile with 3 stars, so the high school lifts the district profile while the elementary sits below it.
Attendance tells the reverse story. Elementary chronic absenteeism is 6.9% — 4.6 points under the district and 9.8 points under the state — while the high school's 17.3% is above both. The high school's graduation rate is 87.7%, matching the district but 2 points below the state. Spending also differs: $10,726 per student at the high school versus $9,041 at the elementary, with a lower student-teacher ratio (14.1 vs. 15.5).
Thank you for your feedback!