Summary
Pine Elementary School is a PK–6 school in Michigan City, IN, serving 396 students as part of Michigan City Area Schools, a district ranked 277th of 374 in Indiana. Despite that district context, Pine has momentum: its rank rose from 857th of 1,016 (16th percentile, 1 star) in 2022–2023 to 580th of 1,015 (43rd percentile, 2 stars) in 2025–2026, its highest displayed rank and second straight 2-star year. All-grade ELA proficiency rose from 18.4% to 35.71%, and math from 22.17% to 44.29%. Among same-district nearby schools, Pine is second only to Knapp Elementary School in ELA and math: Knapp is 36.11% ELA and 44.44% math. Pine still trails nearby higher-performing schools in Duneland School Corporation, such as Brummitt Elementary School (93rd percentile, 5 stars) and Bailly Elementary School (80th percentile, 4 stars), plus Discovery Charter School (73rd percentile, 4 stars).
Science is Pine’s clear weak spot. All-grade science proficiency is 19.35%, below the district’s 24.74%, and it trails same-district Knapp Elementary School (44.25%). Nearby higher-performing schools are far ahead: Bailly Elementary School scored 60.81% in science, Newton Yost Elementary School 61.84%, Brummitt Elementary School 52.78%, and Discovery Charter School 46.36%. Grade-level results are uneven. Grades 3 and 5 are bright spots, with ELA and math above state levels, and 5th grade social studies rebounded from 12.24% to 45.76%. Grade 4 is mixed, while grade 6 is weak: math 20% and science 12%, far below district and state.
Pine also faces significant barriers. In 2024–2025, 73.48% of students received free or reduced-price lunch—the highest rate among same-district nearby schools—and chronic absenteeism was 22.6%, down from 37.6% in 2021–2022 but still above the state’s 16.7%. Resources are relatively strong: per-student spending was $15,932 in 2023–2024, and the student-teacher ratio was 12.5, the lowest among nearby schools. Yet Pine Elementary School still trails higher-income peers in ELA and science, suggesting funding and class size alone are not enough. The clearest priorities are science, 6th-grade math and science, 4th-grade ELA and math, and continuing to reduce absenteeism. With those improvements, Pine could strengthen its position within Michigan City Area Schools.
Thank you for your feedback!