Summary:
The area has two K–8 schools, Legacy Traditional School - Surprise and Legacy Online Academy, with 2025–26 English language arts (ELA) and math results; Surprise also reports 2024–25 science results. The clearest finding is a sharp split: Surprise is above the state in both all-grades subjects, while Online Academy is below it in both.
Surprise leads on the all-grades results, with 57% proficient in ELA and 45% in math, compared with 39% and 15% at Online Academy. That’s an 18-point school-to-school gap in ELA and a 30-point gap in math. Surprise is 16 points above the state in ELA and 12 points above in math; Online Academy is 2 points below the state in ELA and 18 points below in math. Online Academy’s notable bright spot is fifth-grade ELA: 52% proficient, 14 points above the state and 6 points above Surprise. Surprise also exceeds the state in fifth- and eighth-grade science, with 40% and 41% proficient, respectively.
SchoolDigger rates Surprise at the 75th percentile with four stars, versus Online Academy at the 58th percentile with three stars. Both rankings rose from 2024–25: Surprise from the 70th to 75th percentile and Online Academy from the 40th to 58th; across 2023–24 to 2025–26, Surprise is down 2 percentile points while Online Academy is up 9. Grade-level results add useful context: Surprise is above the state in ELA in every reported grade, but its eighth-grade math is 6 points below the state (24% versus 30%). Online Academy’s ELA varies by grade, from above the state in grades 5–7 to 11 points below in grades 4 and 8; its third-grade result is suppressed. Surprise reports a student–teacher ratio of 46:1, compared with 22.2:1 at Online Academy, but those figures alone do not explain the score differences. The supplied data do not include multi-year proficiency results, and free/reduced-lunch figures are blank.
Thank you for your feedback!