Summary:
The Tuscaloosa County school district includes 19 elementary schools serving grades PK through 5th, with enrollments ranging from 206 students at Buhl Elementary School to 744 students at Lake View Elementary School, and the district overall ranks in the 37th percentile statewide.
There is a clear split between a group of high-performing schools and a group of struggling schools. Westwood Elementary School and FaucettVestavia Elementary School are the standouts, both ranking in the 86th percentile statewide with strong English and science scores—Westwood posts 87.76% proficiency in 3rd grade English and 81.67% in 4th grade science, while FaucettVestavia hits 86% in 4th grade English. Huntington Place Elementary School (80th percentile) and Buhl Elementary School (71st percentile) also perform well above the district average. At the other end, Holt Elementary School (6th percentile) and Cottondale Elementary School (7th percentile) struggle significantly, with math proficiency rates below 8% in some grades. The gap is stark: in 3rd grade math, Westwood achieves 68% proficiency while Holt achieves just 7.46%.
Math is the district's biggest challenge, with proficiency rates running 9-15 points below state averages across all grade levels, while English scores are much closer to state norms. Smaller schools tend to outperform larger ones—the top five schools average about 299 students versus 455 for the bottom five. Interestingly, chronic absenteeism is not the main driver of low performance; Holt Elementary School has relatively low absenteeism (6.8%) despite its low ranking. Per-student spending also shows no clear relationship with outcomes, as Huntington Place Elementary School spends the least ($7,650) yet ranks in the 80th percentile. For parents, the takeaway is that school choice within this district matters enormously, with the highest-performing schools offering outcomes that rival the best in the state.
Thank you for your feedback!