Summary:
Vance, Alabama is served by two public schools within the Tuscaloosa County district, which together educate 1,189 students across grades PK-8 in a community where roughly half of all students qualify for free or reduced lunch.
For parents comparing the two schools, Vance Elementary School is the clear standout. It offers a much more favorable student-teacher ratio of 14.9:1 compared to Brookwood Middle School's 19.9:1, and it also spends significantly more per student ($8,576 vs. $6,930). Academically, Vance Elementary outperforms its middle school counterpart in nearly every subject. Its 5th-grade English Language Arts proficiency rate of 67.16% nearly matches the state average, and its 4th-grade Science score of 46.27% exceeds the district average. The elementary school also has a lower chronic absenteeism rate (9.6%) than both the middle school (12.3%) and the state average (12.0%). In contrast, Brookwood Middle School struggles across the board, with math proficiency rates plummeting to just 9.6% by 8th grade and ELA scores trailing state averages by 10-19 percentage points.
The most concerning trend is the dramatic "middle school slide" at Brookwood, where academic performance declines steadily from 6th to 8th grade in both math and ELA. Meanwhile, math is a critical weakness for the entire community—roughly 75-90% of students at both schools are not proficient in the subject. However, there are bright spots: Vance Elementary's strong 5th-grade ELA results suggest successful instructional strategies in the upper elementary grades, and its overall performance relative to the district indicates effective use of resources. For parents, the data clearly points to Vance Elementary as the stronger choice, though both schools face significant challenges that warrant attention from the district.
Thank you for your feedback!