Summary:
ZIP code 54911 in Appleton, Wisconsin contains 11 schools — seven elementary, two middle, one high school and one alternative school — all part of the Appleton Area School District, which is rated 253rd of 432 districts (41st percentile, 2 stars). Together they enroll 4,355 students, though that single district rating masks enormous variation: individual schools here range from 1 star to 5 stars.
Classical School is the academic standout, ranking 69th of 1,039 elementary schools (93rd percentile, 5 stars) and scoring above the state in every reported subject, including 4th grade math at 88.89% versus 52.87% statewide — all while spending the least per student ($12,191). Einstein Middle is the strongest middle school (186th of 643, 71st percentile, 4 stars), with 6th grade ELA at 74.71% versus 54.95% statewide. Wisconsin Connections Academy stands out differently: chronic absenteeism of just 4.8% and a 90% graduation rate, but generally low test scores and a 32.5 student-teacher ratio.
Other schools face bigger challenges. Huntley Elementary fell from 73rd percentile and 4 stars in 2023-2024 to 34th percentile and 2 stars in 2025-2026, with 3rd grade math at 25%. Edison Elementary (1 star) and Kaleidoscope Academy (2 stars) post math scores well below state despite above-average spending. The Omolade Academy, with only 23 students, has the highest spending ($20,603) and highest free/reduced lunch rate (73.91%). Absenteeism ranges widely — from 4.8% at Wisconsin Connections Academy to 34.4% at Valley New School — and enrollment is concentrated, with Einstein Middle and Wisconsin Connections Academy alone enrolling about 36.6% of the ZIP's students.
Thank you for your feedback!