Summary:
Zip code 53119 is home to two elementary schools: Eagle Elementary, a PK–5 school with 234 students in the Palmyra-Eagle Area School District, and Eagleville Charter School, a K–6 school with 95 students in the Mukwonago School District. Both are small, so year-to-year results can swing noticeably.
Eagleville Charter School is the stronger of the two academically. Its district ranks 30th of 432 districts statewide (93rd percentile, 5 stars), and the school itself ranked 317th of 1,039 schools (69th percentile, 3 stars) in 2025–2026. It also has very low chronic absenteeism at 3.2%, compared with 17.3% statewide, and a free/reduced lunch rate of 17.89%. Eagle Elementary ranks 699th of 1,039 (33rd percentile, 2 stars), with its district at 356th of 432 (18th percentile, 1 star). Its absenteeism, 8.5%, is still below its district's 12.5% and the state's 17.3%. Eagle has a lower student-teacher ratio, 10.1 versus 15.3, and spends more per student, $18,944 versus $15,283.
On Forward Exam subject averages, Eagleville outscored both Eagle and the state in most subjects in both years, with Social Studies especially strong at 84.62% and 83.33% proficient. Eagle showed pockets of above-state performance, such as 4th grade ELA at 57.5% and 3rd grade Math at 58.06% in 2025–2026, but also weaker spots, including 5th grade ELA at 25%. Both schools slipped in rank over three years, Eagleville from the 87th to the 69th percentile and Eagle from the 52nd to the 33rd. Higher spending at Eagle does not translate into higher proficiency here; its free/reduced lunch rate, 40.17%, is more than double Eagleville's.
Thank you for your feedback!