Summary
Eagleville Charter School is a small K–6 charter school with 95 students in Eagle, WI, part of the Mukwonago School District, a high-performing district ranked 30th of 432 Wisconsin districts.
Eagleville’s own statewide standing has fallen sharply. In 2025–2026 it ranked 317th of 1,039 schools (69th percentile, 3 stars), down from 15th of 1,025 (99th percentile, 5 stars) in 2017–2018. Among nearby same-district elementary schools, it is now the smallest and lowest-ranked: Prairie View Elementary (91st percentile, 5 stars), Clarendon Avenue Elementary (90th, 5 stars), Section Elementary (99th, 5 stars), and Rolling Hills Elementary (95th, 5 stars). Math is the biggest gap: Eagleville’s 2025–2026 math average was 57.1% proficient versus 82.4% district and 53.3% state. ELA was 68.1% versus 77.3% district and 53.6% state. Grade 4 math was 46.15%, below the state’s 52.87%, and early grades were weaker than grades 5–6. Eagleville also spends more per student ($15,283) than these peers and has the highest student–teacher ratio (15.3), up from 11.9 in 2022–2023.
Strengths include very low chronic absenteeism (3.2% in 2024–2025, versus 3.8% district and 17.3% state) and strong grade 4 social studies (84.62%, above district and state). Science (53.85%) is near the state average but below the district’s 75.46%. Some subgroup effectiveness rankings have slipped, and the school’s small size means yearly results can swing with just a few students. Compared with Eagle Elementary in the Palmyra-Eagle Area School District—ranked 699th of 1,039 (33rd percentile, 2 stars), with higher absenteeism (8.5%), much higher free/reduced lunch (40.17%), and higher per-pupil spending ($18,944)—the school still looks relatively effective. The main concern is that Eagleville, while above state averages in ELA and math, has fallen well behind its own high-performing Mukwonago peers, especially in math and early grades.
Thank you for your feedback!