Summary:
ZIP code 53119 is served by just two elementary schools — Eagle Elementary (PK–5, 234 students) and Eagleville Charter School (K–6, 95 students) — with no middle, high, or alternative schools in the data, so families here eventually move on to schools outside the ZIP. The two schools sit in very different district contexts: Eagle Elementary is part of the Palmyra-Eagle Area School District, ranked 356 of 432 districts (18th percentile, 1 star), while Eagleville Charter belongs to the Mukwonago School District, ranked 30 of 432 (93rd percentile, 5 stars).
Eagleville Charter has the stronger overall profile. In 2025–2026 it ranked 317 of 1,039 schools (69th percentile, 3 stars) versus Eagle Elementary's 699 of 1,039 (33rd percentile, 2 stars), and its chronic absenteeism is exceptionally low at 3.2%, compared with Eagle's 8.5% and the state's 17.3%. On 2025–2026 Forward Exams Eagleville scored well above Eagle in 5th grade ELA (76.47% vs. 25%), 5th grade math (70.59% vs. 34.38%), and 4th grade social studies (84.62% vs. 57.5%). Eagle held smaller edges in 4th grade ELA and 3rd/4th grade math. Notably, Eagle spends more per student ($18,944 vs. $15,283) and has a lower student-teacher ratio (10.1 vs. 15.3), but also a higher free/reduced lunch rate (40.17% vs. 17.89%) and more absenteeism. Eagle's 5th grade results are a clear weak spot, and its ELA 5 score fell from 64.29% the prior year.
Two caveats matter for parents. First, both schools have slipped in rank over three years — Eagle from 52% to 36% to 33rd percentile, Eagleville from 87% to 78% to 69% — even though Eagleville remains much higher. Second, with only 95 students at Eagleville, each grade has roughly 14 students, so year-to-year swings may reflect small-group variation rather than lasting trends. One useful nuance: Eagle Elementary ranks above its own district average, while Eagleville ranks below its very high-performing district average.
Thank you for your feedback!