Summary
Nathan Hale High is a public high school in West Allis, Wisconsin, serving grades 9–12 with 1,134 students as part of the West Allis-West Milwaukee School District. The district ranks 400th of 432 districts in Wisconsin (7th percentile, 0 stars), while the school ranks 346th of 533 high schools in 2025–2026 (35th percentile, 2 stars) — the best result in its available history, up from the 6th percentile in 2022–2023 and the 10th in 2023–2024.
In 2025–2026, 10th-grade proficiency was 48.95% in social studies, 44.44% in English language arts, 27.98% in math, and 30.45% in science. That beats the district in all four subjects by roughly 8 to 16 points, and only social studies is at or above the state average; math and science trail the state by about 15 and 13 points. Nathan Hale High also outperforms Central High, Deeper Learning Virtual Academy, Greenfield High, and Hamilton High in every subject, but sits well below West High, New Berlin West Middle/High, East High, Eisenhower Middle/High, and Whitnall High. Its graduation rate is 89.3%, above the district's 87.2% but below the state's 92.0%, and chronic absenteeism is 18.8%, down from 35.0% in 2020–2021. Free/reduced lunch stands at 57.14%, and the student-teacher ratio of 16.0 is higher than most nearby schools.
Subgroup results are mixed: the school's relative effectiveness is strongest for African American students, English Language Learner students, and special education students, while low-income students remain in the 28th percentile with 1 star — a clear area for targeted support. Per-student spending of $14,879 is similar to Eisenhower Middle/High and higher than Whitnall High, so spending alone does not explain the gap. Overall, Nathan Hale High is a strengthening school and a bright spot within a low-ranked district, but math, science, and support for low-income students are the clearest priorities.
Thank you for your feedback!