Summary
Kiel High is a public high school serving grades 9–12 in Kiel, Wisconsin, with 375 students, and is part of the Kiel Area School District, which ranks 189th of 432 districts in the state. Kiel High itself is ranked 175th of 533 Wisconsin high schools in 2025–2026 (67th percentile, 3 stars) — a major turnaround from 2018–2021, when it sat in the bottom quarter of the state at 23rd and 21st percentile with 1 star. Among nearby schools, it currently trails Elkhart Lake High, New Holstein High, Howards Grove High, and Chilton High, but leads Plymouth High, Valders High, Hilbert High, and Reedsville Junior/Senior High School.
Completion and attendance are Kiel High's clearest strengths. Its 2024–2025 graduation rate was 98.1%, its dropout rate 0.8%, and chronic absenteeism 4.1% — far better than the state's 92.0%, 1.1%, and 17.3%, and better than most nearby schools, including Plymouth High (20.6% chronic absenteeism). Academically, the picture is split. English language arts (62.07% proficient, 10th grade ACT) and science (54.02%) both beat the state, while social studies (43.59% on the Forward Exam) has been below the state for four straight years. Math is inconsistent: it reached 57.33% in 2024–2025 before falling to 42.53% in 2025–2026, essentially at the state average and below several nearby peers.
The biggest red flag is subgroup performance. Effectiveness for low-income students dropped from the 73rd percentile (4 stars) in 2024–2025 to the 9th percentile (0 stars) in 2025–2026 — a sharp, sudden decline, though the subgroup is small (about 18.67% of students receive free/reduced lunch), which can make rankings volatile. Kiel High also spends more per student ($17,983) than every nearby regular high school, yet has the highest student-teacher ratio in that group (14.9), and still trails Elkhart Lake, New Holstein, Howards Grove, and Chilton in overall rank. The same-district Kiel eSchool is not directly comparable, with a lower overall rank and a 9.6% dropout rate.
Thank you for your feedback!