Summary
Smithson Craighead Academy is a K-5 elementary school in Madison, TN, serving 319 students as part of Metro Nashville Public Schools. Within a district ranked 126th of 141 in Tennessee, this school stands out for its steady upward climb: it moved from the 11th percentile statewide in 2023-24 to the 32nd percentile in 2025-26, earning a 2-star rating. That is its best ranking in available data, and it now sits ahead of several nearby schools, including Chadwell Elementary School, Stratton Elementary School, Amqui Elementary School, and Neely's Bend Elementary School.
The school's biggest academic strength is English language arts (ELA). Proficiency has roughly doubled in three years, from 20.4% in 2022-23 to 40.1% in 2025-26, essentially matching the state average (40.6%) and far exceeding the district average (31.8%). Among nearby schools, only Dan Mills Elementary School, Old Center Elementary School, and Pennington Elementary School do better. The 3rd grade class is exceptional, with 61.8% proficient in ELA and 55.6% in math — among the best in the local cluster. However, that progress fades sharply in upper grades: 5th grade ELA proficiency drops to 13.6% and math to 13.0%. Math and science overall remain below state averages, though math improved dramatically this year. The school has also made significant strides with historically underserved students, with Hispanic, low-income, and special education students now scoring around or above the state median for their groups.
Attendance has improved notably — chronic absenteeism fell from 36.6% in 2021-22 to 21.3% in 2024-25, now below the district average. Still, the highest-performing nearby schools have far lower rates, with Dan Mills at 10.4% and Gateway Elementary School at 12.8%. Smithson Craighead also spends more per student than any peer school — roughly $26,900, versus about $17,400 at Dan Mills, which posts the cluster's highest test scores. That spending may be funding smaller classes (the student-teacher ratio improved from 19.7 to 13.8) or targeted interventions beginning to show results. For parents, this is a school with genuine momentum, especially in early grades and reading, but the math/science gaps and upper-grade decline are worth watching.
Thank you for your feedback!