Summary
Mitchell-Neilson Elementary School in Murfreesboro, TN, serves 619 students in grades PK–6 as part of Murfreesboro City Schools. The school currently ranks 847th out of 1,019 Tennessee elementary schools — the 17th percentile with a 1-star rating — marking the third consecutive year in the bottom fifth of the state. This continues a longer pattern: the school has ranked in the bottom 6th–19th percentile for most of the past decade, with only a brief improvement to the 52nd percentile during the pandemic-affected 2020–21 school year.
Academically, Mitchell-Neilson trails its district and state in nearly every subject and grade level. In 2025–26, just 32.2% of students scored proficient in math, 26.5% in English language arts, 23.9% in science, and 29.2% in social studies. Science shows the widest gap at 23 points below the state average, and proficiency falls sharply as students get older — 6th-grade science proficiency is just 12.5% compared with 48.0% statewide. A nearby comparison highlights the challenge: Northfield Elementary School, less than a mile away in the same district, ranks in the 43rd percentile and outperforms Mitchell-Neilson in math, ELA, and science — all while spending about $1,000 less per student.
Attendance and resource use are major concerns. Chronic absenteeism has hovered between 18% and 20% in recent years, roughly double the district rate. Per-pupil spending has risen 19% over four years to $16,152, yet outcomes have remained flat, and support for high-need students appears to have weakened — English Language Learner subgroup rankings dropped from the 46th to the 9th percentile in a single year, and special education rankings have fallen similarly. On a more encouraging note, social studies proficiency was slightly above the district average, and Mitchell-Neilson's strength in that subject may point to instructional practices worth building on. Still, among nearby schools in an already struggling cluster, only Reeves-Rogers Elementary School ranks lower, meaning the school faces real work to turn its trajectory around.
Thank you for your feedback!