Summary:
The three elementary schools in Chester Area School District 39-1 serve children from prekindergarten through eighth grade: Chester Elementary -02 serves PK–5, while Rustic Acres Colony Elementary - 04 and Gracevale Colony Elementary - 07 serve K–8. The latest reported all-grades results show a sharp difference between the two schools with results in both subjects, especially in math.
Chester Elementary -02 stands out among schools with reported 2025–2026 all-grades results: 48% were proficient in ELA and 44% in math, close to the state rates of 49% and 44%. Rustic Acres Colony Elementary - 04 was lower, at 29% in ELA and 10% in math—about 20 and 34 percentage points below the state. The gap between these schools was about 20 points in ELA and 35 in math. At Chester, fourth-grade ELA was a brighter spot at 65%, while fifth-grade science was 28%, about 14 points below the state. Gracevale’s current all-grades results are suppressed, so it cannot be ranked alongside them.
Recent trends differ by school and subject: from 2024–2025 to 2025–2026, Chester’s ELA fell about 8 points and math about 13, while Rustic Acres’ ELA rose about 4 points but math fell about 7. SchoolDigger’s statewide ranking for Chester also moved from the 63rd percentile in 2024–2025 to the 33rd in 2025–2026; Rustic Acres and Gracevale were at the 16th and 9th percentiles in 2024–2025. School size and ratios do not give a simple guide to results: Chester enrolled 154 students, with 15.4 students per teacher, compared with 41 and 13.6 at Rustic Acres and 23 and 11.5 at Gracevale. Reported free/reduced lunch eligible figures were 20% for Chester in 2024–2025 and 8% for Rustic Acres and 20% for Gracevale in 2022–2023. These figures are context, not an explanation for test results.
Thank you for your feedback!