Summary
Metcalf School in Exeter, RI, serves grades 2–6 and enrolls 522 students in the Exeter-West Greenwich district. Its 2025–26 test results were above Rhode Island’s in ELA, math and science, though comparisons with nearby schools and its district are more mixed. The most important caution is that SchoolDigger’s statewide effectiveness percentile for students receiving special education services fell to 25, well below the school’s overall 81st percentile.
ELA is Metcalf’s clearest strength against nearby schools, while science is its weakest relative result. Metcalf scored 50% in ELA, 47% in math and 45% in science—17, 15 and 14 percentage points above state results, respectively. Compared with the district, it was 1 point lower in ELA, 2 points higher in math and 4 points lower in science. Against nearby-school averages, Metcalf was 8 points higher in ELA, 2 points higher in math and 6 points lower in science; it ranked sixth of eight schools in ELA, fourth of eight in math and fourth of six in science. Within Metcalf, fifth grade was the clearest soft spot: proficiency was 42% in ELA and 41% in math, the lowest of the reported grades in each subject.
All three subjects improved from 2024–25 to 2025–26, rebounding by 5 points in ELA, 2 in math and 6 in science, but results have varied from year to year. SchoolDigger rates Metcalf 4 stars and ranks it 31st of 163 Rhode Island schools, at the 81st percentile; that is fourth among eight nearby schools with current rankings. Its percentile rose 12 points from the previous year. The student-teacher ratio was 12.7, below the nearby average of 13.6, and 25% of students qualified for free or reduced-price lunch, compared with a nearby average of 29%. SchoolDigger’s percentile for low socioeconomic status students rose to 84, while its Hispanic students’ percentile rose to 64—17 points below Metcalf’s overall standing.
Thank you for your feedback!