Summary
Cuyahoga Hts Elementary School is a PK–5 school of 352 students at 4880 E 71st St in Garfield Heights, OH, and it serves as the elementary anchor of the Cuyahoga Heights Local district — a district ranked 58th of 773 in Ohio (92nd percentile, 5 stars), far out of step with the buildings around it, which belong to Cleveland Municipal (11th percentile, 1 star) or are standalone charters ranked between the 2nd and 11th percentiles. The school's own record is that of a durable high performer with a mild, long-run softening at the very top: it peaked at the 96th percentile a decade ago, dipped to the 72nd in 2020–21, and has since settled into the 85th–89th percentile band — 89th percentile in 2025–26, up from 80th the prior year.
Academically, results are strong across the board. In 2025–26 the school beat the Ohio state rate in all seven reported subject and grade combinations, by margins of +11.6 to +29.0 points, and all 28 reported test records from 2022–23 through 2025–26 exceed the state rate. Against nearby schools the difference is categorical rather than incremental: Grade 3 math was 82.7% here versus 0%–45.7% nearby, Grade 3 ELA 75.0% versus 12.5%–62.5%, and chronic absenteeism 4.3% versus 46.5%–80.3% at neighboring buildings. Two neighbors deserve mention: Northstar School of Innovation & Leadership matched the school at some grades (92.9% Grade 5 science, 90.5% Grade 4 math) but is small and posted 9th–10th percentile results in the prior two years, and Washington Park Community School shows real but isolated bright spots.
Two things parents should weigh together. The school spends $16,218 per pupil (2018–19, the oldest figure available) — the highest in the comparison set, roughly 2x to 2.4x what nearby charters spend — so the results are real and sustained but not evidence they are achievable at comparable cost. Meanwhile, free/reduced lunch eligibility nearly doubled, from 18.93% to about 31%, even as Low SES students ranked at the 85th percentile (98th in 2023–24) and special education students at the 91st percentile. The one open question: gifted and talented students sit at the 39th percentile, 2 stars, but that is a single data point from 2017–18, and no current measure exists.
Thank you for your feedback!