Summary
Bellefontaine High School in Bellefontaine, OH, serves grades 9–12 and enrolls 643 students, making it the largest traditional comprehensive high school in its local comparison group. It is part of Bellefontaine City Schools, a district ranked 442nd of 773 Ohio districts (2 stars). The school itself ranked 408th of 795 high schools in 2025–26 (49th percentile, 2 stars), placing it mid-pack statewide.
Graduation is a clear strength: 99.5% in 2025–26, near the top locally. But chronic absenteeism is 35.0%, the highest among traditional nearby high schools and well above the district’s 25.4% rate. In 2025–26 test scores, Bellefontaine was above the state in Government (75.9), History (78.5), Geometry (49.1), and Algebra I (69.2), but near state in Biology (66.5) and English II (63.0). Compared with nearby schools, it sits middle-to-lower: Algebra I is 5th among 10 nearby tested high schools; Geometry 6th; Government 7th; History 7th; Biology 8th; English II 8th. West Liberty-Salem High School and Jackson Center High School generally outperform by wide margins. Indian Lake High School, Graham High School, and Triad High School also beat Bellefontaine in most subjects. Benjamin Logan High School, the closest peer, is generally ahead. Urbana High School is one of the few nearby schools Bellefontaine outperforms in overall rank and graduation rate.
A positive trend: Bellefontaine improved in every tested subject from 2024–25 to 2025–26, with English II rising from 50.0 to 63.0, Geometry from 38.8 to 49.1, Government from 67.0 to 75.9, and History from 72.1 to 78.5. That lifted the school from the 39th to the 49th percentile, though it remains below its 2021–22 peak of 69th percentile and 3 stars. Math is mixed: Algebra I is a relative strength, while Geometry is middling. English II and Biology are relative weak spots. Subgroup data show the school serves male students more effectively than female students, and low-income and special education students rank below average; gifted students have historically been a major strength. Resources are not the obvious constraint—Bellefontaine spends $11,035 per student, near the top of the comparison group, with a 15.6 student-teacher ratio. The clearest priorities are reducing absenteeism, improving English and biology outcomes, and closing subgroup gaps while preserving graduation and gifted-program strengths.
Thank you for your feedback!