Summary:
Schools in ZIP code 11733 include eight schools in the Three Village Central School District: five elementary schools, two middle schools, and one high school. Overall, the schools’ latest comparable grade-level averages are above state results: elementary students averaged 53% in ELA and 65% in math, versus 44% and 58% statewide, while the middle-school averages were 67% and 63%, versus 51% and 52%. But those area-wide results hide meaningful differences by school and grade—the most important finding for families.
Paul J. Gelinas Middle School leads the middle schools, averaging 75% in grades 6–8 ELA and 70% in math; those results are 16 and 15 percentage points higher, respectively, than at Robert Cushman Murphy Middle School. Gelinas also leads in grade 8 science, 70% to 40%. Among elementary schools, Nassakeag Elementary School has the highest ELA average, 63%, and grade 5 science result, 78%; Minnesauke Elementary School leads in math at 73%. At the lower end, Arrowhead Elementary School averages 43% in ELA and 50% in math, about 22 percentage points below the leading school in each subject. Its grade 5 science result is higher than the state’s, however.
Elementary ELA and math averages fell from the prior year by 15 and 8 percentage points, though they remained above state averages; middle-school results were more mixed, with grades 7–8 averages rising 2 points in ELA and 8 in math, while grade 8 science slipped. SchoolDigger rankings declined at all eight schools from 2023–24 to 2025–26, from a 2-point drop at Gelinas to an 18-point drop at William Sidney Mount Elementary School; Ward Melville was ranked in the 91st percentile, while Arrowhead was in the 48th. Context measures do not explain these differences: the middle schools have similar enrollment and student–teacher ratios—655 students and 10.0 at Murphy, compared with 651 and 10.4 at Gelinas—but different results. Reported free/reduced lunch eligibility in 2024–25 ranged from 9% at Nassakeag to 21% at Murphy.
Thank you for your feedback!