Beta You're viewing our redesigned school list. Prefer the classic layout?

Best Public Schools in Zip Code 11733


At a glance
8
Schools
5,629
Students
1
5-star school
Top rankedPaul J Gelinas Middle School180th of 1,509 New York middle schools
◉
Smallest classes
Robert Cushman Murphy Middle School 10 students per teacher
SchoolDigger ratings
5★
4★
3★
2★
Summary:

Schools in ZIP code 11733 include eight schools in the Three Village Central School District: five elementary schools, two middle schools, and one high school. Overall, the schools’ latest comparable grade-level averages are above state results: elementary students averaged 53% in ELA and 65% in math, versus 44% and 58% statewide, while the middle-school averages were 67% and 63%, versus 51% and 52%. But those area-wide results hide meaningful differences by school and grade—the most important finding for families.

Paul J. Gelinas Middle School leads the middle schools, averaging 75% in grades 6–8 ELA and 70% in math; those results are 16 and 15 percentage points higher, respectively, than at Robert Cushman Murphy Middle School. Gelinas also leads in grade 8 science, 70% to 40%. Among elementary schools, Nassakeag Elementary School has the highest ELA average, 63%, and grade 5 science result, 78%; Minnesauke Elementary School leads in math at 73%. At the lower end, Arrowhead Elementary School averages 43% in ELA and 50% in math, about 22 percentage points below the leading school in each subject. Its grade 5 science result is higher than the state’s, however.

Elementary ELA and math averages fell from the prior year by 15 and 8 percentage points, though they remained above state averages; middle-school results were more mixed, with grades 7–8 averages rising 2 points in ELA and 8 in math, while grade 8 science slipped. SchoolDigger rankings declined at all eight schools from 2023–24 to 2025–26, from a 2-point drop at Gelinas to an 18-point drop at William Sidney Mount Elementary School; Ward Melville was ranked in the 91st percentile, while Arrowhead was in the 48th. Context measures do not explain these differences: the middle schools have similar enrollment and student–teacher ratios—655 students and 10.0 at Murphy, compared with 651 and 10.4 at Gelinas—but different results. Reported free/reduced lunch eligibility in 2024–25 ranged from 9% at Nassakeag to 21% at Murphy.

Ranking:
Map legend
E Elementary M Middle H High A Alternative P Private




Cities Near Zip Code 11733

See the top NY New York cities
SchoolDigger data sources: National Center for Education Statistics, U.S. Department of Education, the U.S. Census Bureau, the WNYC and the New York State Department of Health and the NY State Education Department.

IMPORTANT DISCLAIMERS: Not all boundaries are included. We make every effort to ensure that boundaries are up-to-date. But it's important to note that these are approximations and are for general informational purposes only. To verify legal descriptions of boundaries or school locations, contact your local tax assessor's office and/or school district.

Diagnostics