Summary
Minnesauke Elementary School serves 644 students in prekindergarten through grade 5 in East Setauket, a Long Island community. SchoolDigger gives it 4 stars and an 80th-percentile ranking for 2025–2026, compared with the Three Village Central School District at the 74th percentile, also with 4 stars. The most important takeaway is that Minnesauke’s results are strong across subjects: it outperforms state and district averages in ELA and math in grades 3–5 and in grade 5 science.
Math and science are Minnesauke’s strongest subjects compared with nearby schools, while ELA is a relative weak spot—but still above average. Among eight nearby schools with comparable scores, Minnesauke ranks first in math, second in grade 5 science and third in ELA. Its average results are 73% in math, 75% in science and 59% in ELA, compared with nearby averages of 56%, 55% and 45%, respectively. The advantages over nearby averages are 17 percentage points in math, 21 in science and 14 in ELA. Minnesauke also exceeds state averages by 15 points in math, 30 in science and 14 in ELA, and district averages by 7, 6 and 5 points, respectively. Within the grades, grade 4 math is a standout at 82%, the highest among nearby schools; ELA is less even, with grade 4 less exceptional than grades 3 and 5.
Results have shifted over time: from 2023–2024 to 2025–2026, average ELA fell 7 points, from 66% to 59%, and math fell 11 points, from 84% to 73%; grade 5 science rose 5 points, from 71% to 75%, after dropping to 62% in 2024–2025. SchoolDigger’s overall percentile ranking also declined from 93 to 80 over that period, though the school remains highly ranked. A notable subgroup finding is that SchoolDigger’s 2025–2026 ranking for how well the school serves Special Education Students is at the 63rd percentile, below its 80th-percentile overall ranking; the subgroup ranking fell from the 90th percentile in 2023–2024. As context, the 11.9:1 student-teacher ratio is below the nearby-school average of 12.5:1. In 2024–2025, 14% of students were free/reduced lunch eligible, compared with a 24% average at nearby schools with the same measure and year.
Thank you for your feedback!