Summary:
Zip code 10543 has six schools: three elementary schools, one middle school and two high schools, serving families in the Mamaroneck and Rye Neck school communities. The latest results show strong outcomes in many tested grades and subjects, but performance is not uniform across schools or even across subjects at the same high school. The supplied data have no test-score entries for Daniel Warren Elementary School, so its academic results cannot be compared. The most important takeaway is that families should look at the specific school, grade and subject—not assume one area-wide pattern describes all six schools.
Rye Neck Middle School is the most consistent standout: its average advantage over the state was 25 percentage points in ELA and 28 points in math across grades 6–8, including an 84% eighth-grade math result versus 46% statewide. Among elementary schools, F E Bellows Elementary School leads in five of six grade-matched ELA and math comparisons, as well as fifth-grade science; its fifth-grade math result was 91%, versus 71% at Mamaroneck Avenue School and 54% statewide. Mamaroneck Avenue leads in third-grade ELA, and both elementary schools are above the state in every reported comparison. The high schools have different subject strengths: Rye Neck Senior High School is above the state in every reported Regents result with a numeric score, while Mamaroneck High School is below it in Common Core ELA and Earth Science.
Recent results and SchoolDigger rankings also tell different stories. Mamaroneck Avenue’s SchoolDigger ranking rose from the 57th percentile in 2023–2024 to the 75th in 2025–2026, while F E Bellows remained high but edged down from the 93rd to the 90th percentile; at Bellows, ELA results fell in all three tested grades year over year, even as fifth-grade math rose 9 percentage points. Mamaroneck High’s ranking reached the 93rd percentile, yet its Common Core ELA result fell 24 points from the prior year. Staffing and income figures offer context, not a simple explanation: in 2024–2025, student–teacher ratios were 9.4 at Mamaroneck Avenue and 10.7 at F E Bellows, and both reported the same measure—free/reduced lunch eligible—with rates of 48% and 15%, respectively. Those figures do not predict which school will be stronger in a particular subject.
Thank you for your feedback!