Summary
New Monmouth Elementary School serves 508 students in grades K–5 in Middletown, NJ, alongside several nearby elementary schools. SchoolDigger ranks it in the 55th percentile statewide for 2025–2026, with 3 stars (605th of 1,331 schools). The main takeaway is that its average results are above the state in ELA and math, but below the nearby Middletown-school average in all three tested subjects, including science.
ELA is the school’s strongest subject relative to the state, district and local peers: its grade 3–5 average is 55%, 7 points above the state, though 6 points below the Middletown Township Public School District and 3 points below nearby schools. Math averages 50%, 3 points above the state but 9 below the district and 5 below nearby schools. Science averages 23%, 4 points below the state, 7 below the district and 5 below nearby schools. Results vary by grade: fourth-grade ELA is a clear weak spot at 44%, versus 46% statewide and 60% for both the district and nearby schools. Fifth-grade ELA is a standout at 71%—19 points above the state, 3 above the district and 5 above nearby schools.
Average ELA and math results rose modestly from 2022–2023 to 2025–2026, by 2 points each; fifth-grade science rose 5 points, though it fluctuated in between. The school’s advantage over the state widened by 2 points in ELA, while narrowing by about 2 in math and 4 in science. In 2024–2025, its student-teacher ratio was 12.0, second-highest among seven nearby schools, and 18% of students were free/reduced lunch eligible, also second-highest; these are comparisons, not explanations for test results. SchoolDigger’s subgroup rankings show a notable contrast: its measure of effectiveness for White students ranks at the 31st percentile, compared with 55th overall. For Hispanic students, the ranking fell from the 97th percentile in 2023–2024 to the 60th in 2025–2026, while the overall ranking moved from 62nd to 55th.
Thank you for your feedback!