Summary
Joseph C. Caruso School is a K–5 elementary school in Keansburg, serving 595 students in a community where many students are eligible for free or reduced-price meals. The school’s latest results show a broad academic concern: in 2025–2026, its scores were below the state average and lower than those of nearby schools in every reported grade-and-subject comparison from grades 3–5, including grade 5 science.
Compared with nearby schools and the state, Caruso’s results are weakest across the board, although grade 5 is a relative bright spot in the school’s own ELA results. ELA proficiency was 12% in grade 3, 26% in grade 4, and 29% in grade 5, compared with state rates of 48%, 46%, and 52%. In math, Caruso’s rates were 18%, 22%, and 13%, versus 49%, 47%, and 46% statewide; grade 5 science was 9% compared with 27% statewide. Caruso also had the lowest result among nearby schools in all seven comparisons, including grade 5 ELA (29% versus a nearby-school average of 59%) and grade 5 math (13% versus 50%). The district’s results were almost identical to Caruso’s in nearly every grade and subject, so they provide little different context.
Results have improved in some areas over time, but progress has been uneven: average grade-level ELA and math results each rose 5 points from 2022–2023 to 2025–2026, while the math average fell from 19% to 17% between the last two years. Grade 5 science rose from 9% to 9%. SchoolDigger ranks Caruso in the 9th percentile for 2025–2026, with 0 stars, below nearby schools with current rankings, which range from the 29th to the 77th percentile. In 2024–2025, 76% of students were free/reduced lunch eligible; the nearby-school average was 25%. The student-teacher ratio was comparatively low at 9.6 students per teacher, but that did not coincide with stronger scores in this comparison. Chronic absenteeism was 29% in 2024–2025, compared with 14% statewide. One subgroup ranking stood out: SchoolDigger placed English Language Learner Students at the 24th percentile in 2024–2025, compared with the school’s overall 7th percentile, a higher measure of effectiveness for that group.
Thank you for your feedback!