Summary:
Middletown Township Public School District has 16 schools—11 elementary, three middle and two high schools—serving students from elementary through high school. In 2025–2026, elementary-school averages were above state rates in every listed subject and grade, by 4 to 17 percentage points. But those averages hide wide differences: Grade 3 math results ranged from 12% to 89%, a 77-point spread. The most important finding is that strong overall results do not reflect the experience at every school.
River Plaza Elementary is a standout in Grade 3, with 85% proficient in ELA and 89% in math, compared with school averages of 57% and 58%. Nut Swamp Elementary and Navesink Elementary also post strong Grade 5 results: Navesink leads in ELA (86%), math (75%) and science (50%). At the other end, Ocean Avenue Elementary has the lowest Grade 3 ELA and math results, at 17% and 12%, and Grade 5 results of 47% in ELA, 38% in math and 19% in science. Thompson Middle School leads in most middle-school comparisons, including Grade 8 Algebra I at 99% proficient. At high school, Middletown High School South leads Middletown High School North by 15 points in Grade 9 ELA and 18 points in end-of-course Geometry.
Recent elementary trends are mixed: the Grade 3 ELA average rose 3 points from 2024–2025 to 2025–2026, while Grade 4 ELA fell 7 points and Grade 5 science fell 6. SchoolDigger gives River Plaza five stars and a 94th-percentile ranking; Ocean Avenue has two stars and ranks in the 34th percentile. Low-income measures also differ: free/reduced lunch eligible, school year 2024–2025, ranges from 2% at Nut Swamp to 39% at Ocean Avenue. Attendance offers another point of comparison: chronic absenteeism in 2024–2025 was 2% at River Plaza and 21% at Ocean Avenue. These figures provide context, not an explanation for differences in school results.
Thank you for your feedback!