Summary
Central Avenue School is a PK–5 elementary school serving 492 students in Madison, New Jersey, in the Madison Public School District. Its overall results are strong, but the clearest concern for parents is a sharp fourth-to-fifth-grade contrast in mathematics: 56% of fourth graders were proficient, compared with 92% of fifth graders in 2025–2026.
Fifth grade is a standout, while fourth-grade math is the main weakness. Central Avenue’s fifth-grade math result was 92%, above the district’s 86%, the state’s 46%, and the nearby-school average of 72%; it was the highest among the nearby schools with results. By contrast, fourth-grade math was 56%, below the district’s 64% and nearby average of 67%, though above the state’s 47%; it was just below Brooklake School at 56%. ELA is a relative strength: across grades 3–5, Central Avenue averaged 77%, compared with 71% for nearby schools and 49% for the state. Its fifth-grade science result was 2 points below the district, making science its weakest subject relative to district results.
Results have shifted unevenly rather than improving or declining across the board: from 2022–2023 to 2025–2026, average math proficiency fell 2 points, while fourth-grade math dropped 29 points and fifth-grade math rose 20 points. SchoolDigger ranks Central Avenue at the 89th percentile statewide and gives it 4 stars in 2025–2026, close to the district’s 88th percentile and 4 stars; among six nearby schools with current rankings, Central Avenue is third. Its standing has risen from the 62nd percentile in 2015–2016, after peaking at 94 in 2023–2024. In 2024–2025, its student-teacher ratio was 10.6, compared with a nearby average of 10.3, and 8% of students were free/reduced lunch eligible. SchoolDigger’s ranking for Low Socio Economic Status Students was at the 65th percentile in 2024–2025, 23 points below the school’s overall 88th-percentile ranking, a notable difference in how well it ranks in serving this group.
Thank you for your feedback!