Summary:
The 11 schools in Montclair Public School District span elementary, middle, and high school, with grades ranging from pre-K through grade 12. Across the six elementary schools with reported scores, average proficiency was 73% in ELA, 67% in math, and 50% in grade 5 science, compared with state averages of 49%, 47%, and 27%. But math results are not strong across every grade: at Montclair High School, Algebra I was 15% in grade 9 versus 22% statewide, and grade 8 regular math at Buzz Aldrin Middle School was 6% versus 23%. The most important takeaway is that strong elementary averages sit alongside significant middle- and high-school math weaknesses.
Elementary leaders vary by grade: Watchung Elementary School led grade 3 ELA and math at 82% and 86%, but had the lowest grade 5 ELA and math results, at 71% and 61%. Bradford Elementary School led grade 5 ELA at 82%—30 points above the state—and grade 4 math at 74%; Charles H. Bullock School led grade 5 science at 56%, 29 points above the state. Among middle schools, Renaissance Middle School at the Rand Building led several ELA and math tests, while leadership shifted to Glenfield Middle School in grade 7 ELA and Buzz Aldrin in grade 7 math. At Montclair High, ELA, science, and NJGPA results exceeded state results, while Algebra I and Geometry results fell short.
Elementary results improved relative to the state from 2024–2025 to 2025–2026: the average school-versus-state gap grew by about 4 points across comparable tests. Middle-school trends were mixed, and Montclair High’s Algebra II proficiency fell 37 points, from 96% to 59%. SchoolDigger ranks Bradford at the 88th percentile and Watchung at the 87th among elementary schools, and gives the district an 80th-percentile ranking with four stars. Contextual measures also differ: scored elementary schools’ student-teacher ratios range from 9.5 at Bradford to 14.6 at Hillside; free/reduced lunch eligible (sy 2024–2025) ranges from 8% at Bradford to 19% at Northeast. Nishuane serves Pre-K–2 and has no supplied test scores, and other middle-school grade 8 math results are suppressed.
Thank you for your feedback!