Summary:
West Orange Public Schools includes 11 schools—seven elementary schools, three middle schools and one high school—for families in West Orange. In 2025–2026, elementary schools averaged 62% in ELA and 61% in math across grades 3–5, above state averages of 49% and 47%; middle-school averages were 56% in ELA and 36% in math, compared with 53% and 34% statewide. The most important finding is that elementary results differ substantially by school: ELA averages span 32 points, from St. Cloud Elementary School to Washington Elementary School.
St. Cloud leads elementary ELA at 77% and fifth-grade science at 57%; Mount Pleasant Elementary School narrowly leads math at 71%, just ahead of St. Cloud at 71%. Gregory Elementary School is also strong, averaging 75% in ELA and 69% in math, and has the highest listed SchoolDigger ranking: the 88th percentile. At the other end, Washington averages 46% in ELA and 44% in math, below state averages in both. Kelly Elementary School is more mixed: its ELA average is 47%, while its math average is 52%. In middle school, Roosevelt Middle School leads ELA at 61%, while Edison Middle School leads math at 40%. At West Orange High School, Geometry proficiency is 79%, well above the state’s 50%, but Algebra II is 3%, far below the state’s 53%.
Recent elementary trends differ by subject: from 2024–2025 to 2025–2026, ELA fell about 4 points on average while math rose about 3. Individual changes also vary: Mount Pleasant’s ELA average fell about 12 points, while Hazel Avenue Elementary School’s math average rose about 8. SchoolDigger’s ranking history also differs: Gregory rose 5 percentile points from 2023–2024 to 2025–2026, while Liberty Middle School fell 7. As context, the 2024–2025 free/reduced lunch eligible measure was 15% at St. Cloud and 75% at Washington; these figures describe school context, not the cause of results.
Thank you for your feedback!