Summary
Watchung Elementary School enrolls 406 students in grades K–5 in Montclair, where families have several nearby public schools to compare. Its 2025–2026 results were well above state proficiency averages, and its SchoolDigger ranking placed it among the stronger schools in the area. The central takeaway is that Watchung’s strongest results are in grades 3 and 4, while fifth grade—especially math—is a clear relative weak spot.
Watchung’s average proficiency across grades 3–5 was 76% in ELA and 71% in math, compared with 66% and 62% across seven nearby schools with results for all three grades. It also exceeded the averages of its four nearby Montclair peers in both subjects, though Brookdale Elementary School had a higher three-grade math average. Watchung led nearby schools in third-grade ELA and math, but its fifth-grade ELA and math results were below all four nearby Montclair peers. Against the Montclair Public School District, Watchung averaged 3 points higher in ELA and 5 points higher in math, but fifth-grade science was 5 points lower. It was above state averages in ELA, math, and science, by 27, 24, and 19 points, respectively.
Results have improved overall since 2022–2023: the grade 3–5 averages rose from 66% to 76% in ELA and from 63% to 71% in math, with much of the improvement concentrated in grade 3. SchoolDigger placed Watchung at the 87th percentile statewide, rank 174 of 1,331, with four stars in 2025–2026; its percentile had been 80 the year before, and nearby Brookdale ranked at the 89th percentile. In 2024–2025, the school had 11.9 students per teacher, chronic absenteeism of 8.2% versus 8.1% districtwide, and a free/reduced lunch eligible rate of 9% in 2024–2025. SchoolDigger’s statewide measure for how well Watchung serves Low Socio Economic Status Students was at the 46th percentile in 2024–2025, 34 points below the school’s overall percentile of 80. Its measure for how well the school serves Special Education Students rose sharply, from the 58th percentile in 2023–2024 to the 92nd in 2025–2026, five points above the overall percentile that year.
Thank you for your feedback!