Summary:
Zip code 28786 in Waynesville, North Carolina is home to two public middle schools—Waynesville Middle and Bethel Middle—both part of Haywood County Schools, serving grades 6 through 8 in an area where more than 97% of students at each school qualify for free or reduced-price lunch.
Bethel Middle is the clear standout in this area. It has ranked in the top quarter of North Carolina middle schools for three straight years, earning a 5-star rating in 2023–2024, while Waynesville Middle has held a 3-star rating over that same period. In the most recent testing year, Bethel scored above the state average in every subject except 7th grade math and posted an outstanding 83.5% proficiency rate in 8th grade science. Waynesville also performs at or above state averages in all tested areas, but trails Bethel in most subjects—for example, 8th grade reading proficiency is 69.4% at Bethel versus 56.1% at Waynesville, and 8th grade math is 74.1% versus 63.6%. Bethel previously held even larger leads in 7th grade math and 8th grade science.
Chronic absenteeism may help explain the gap. Bethel's chronic absenteeism rate is just 16.7%, well below the district average of 19.9% and the state average of 24.2%, while Waynesville's rate stands at a concerning 27.7%. Bethel also spends more per student ($11,023 versus $9,343) and has a slightly lower student-teacher ratio. Because Bethel is a smaller school with 254 students, its grade-level scores can swing significantly between cohorts—7th grade math proficiency fell from 83.3% to 55.1% in one year—so parents should weigh multi-year trends. Overall, both schools serve their communities well given very high poverty levels, but Bethel Middle is the higher-performing school in zip code 28786.
Thank you for your feedback!