Summary
Tiller School is a small K–5 elementary school in Beaufort, NC, serving 206 students and operating as its own single-school district, the Tiller School district, which ranks 27th out of 246 North Carolina districts (89th percentile, 4 stars). The school itself is currently ranked 340th out of 1,492 elementary schools statewide (77th percentile, 4 stars). Tiller was historically a top-tier performer, placing in the top 50–70 schools statewide in the mid-to-late 2010s, and while it dipped to the 62nd percentile in 2022–2023, it has since recovered to the upper-middle tier of the state — though it has not yet returned to its former 5-star, top-100 level.
Reading is Tiller’s clearest academic strength. In 2025–2026, reading proficiency was well above the state average at every grade level: 73.3% of both 4th and 5th graders were proficient, compared with state rates near 56–58%. This is especially notable compared with Beaufort Elementary, the closest comparator at just 0.82 miles away, where 4th grade reading proficiency was 25.7 percentage points lower. Math is strong overall but uneven: 3rd grade (78.1%) and 5th grade (83.3%) are well above state averages, while 4th grade math (56.7%) fell below the state and below several nearby schools. Science has been inconsistent, with 5th grade proficiency at 70.0% — only slightly above the state and trailing strong neighbors like Bogue Sound Elementary (84.6%) and Atlantic Elementary (90.0%).
Tiller also stands out for its low 11.4-to-1 student-teacher ratio, better than most nearby schools, and its chronic absenteeism rate has improved dramatically from 28.9% in 2022–2023 to 15.0% in 2024–2025 — well below the state rate of 24.2%. The school has also posted notably strong recent outcomes for economically disadvantaged students, ranking in the 82nd–91st percentile for that subgroup over the past two years. However, because Tiller is small, grade-level scores and subgroup rankings can swing considerably from year to year; a single cohort of 30–40 students can shift results by 10 points or more. Overall, Tiller remains a high-quality option in the Beaufort area, clearly ahead of most of its closest geographic peers, though Bogue Sound Elementary and Morehead Elementary at Camp Glenn currently post slightly stronger statewide rankings.
Thank you for your feedback!