Summary:
Zip code 48457 is home to two high schools serving grades 8-12 within the Montrose Community Schools district in Michigan, together enrolling roughly 648 students in a community where over half of students qualify for free or reduced lunch.
For parents, the most important takeaway is that these two schools offer vastly different educational experiences. Hill-McCloy High School is the district's clear academic leader, ranking in the 70th percentile statewide and earning a 3-star rating after a remarkable one-year jump from the 41st percentile. It boasts a 95.1% graduation rate, well above the state average, and outperforms Michigan in science (60.5% proficient vs. 35.2% state), social studies, and SAT reading/writing. However, its SAT math proficiency (19.7%) lags the state average (26.5%), a notable weakness. In stark contrast, Montrose Alternative Education Center ranks in the bottom 2% of Michigan high schools with a 0-star rating for three consecutive years. Its graduation rate is just 59.0%, and test scores trail the state by 30-40 percentage points in nearly every subject.
The disparity between these two schools is striking, especially regarding resources. Hill-McCloy spends $14,981 per student with a 16.9:1 student-teacher ratio, while Montrose Alternative spends only $7,013 per student and has a 42.3:1 ratio—meaning the students with the greatest academic needs receive the least support. This resource gap, combined with the alternative school's higher poverty rate (65.8% free/reduced lunch), likely compounds its challenges. While Hill-McCloy demonstrates that high-poverty schools can achieve strong results, the district's overall 74.0% graduation rate is dragged down by Montrose Alternative's struggles. For parents, choosing Hill-McCloy offers a proven, improving academic environment, while Montrose Alternative serves a specific population but faces severe obstacles that warrant careful consideration.
Thank you for your feedback!