Summary:
Montrose Community Schools is a small Michigan district serving roughly 1,435 students across four schools—one elementary, one middle, and two high schools—in a predominantly low-income area where free/reduced lunch rates range from about 52% to 66%.
The standout is HillMcCloy High School, which posted a 95.1% graduation rate and jumped from the 41st to 70th percentile in state rankings in just one year. Its 11th graders far exceed state averages in science (60.5% vs. 35.2%), social studies (54.7% vs. 43.2%), and reading/writing (61.8% vs. 52.1%), though math proficiency (19.7%) lags the state by nearly 7 points. By contrast, Montrose Alternative Education Center ranks in the bottom 2% of Michigan high schools, with a 59% graduation rate, an 11.3% dropout rate, and a staggering 42.3:1 student-teacher ratio—more than double any other school in the district. Carter Elementary School is another bright spot: despite having the highest poverty rate (65.9% free/reduced lunch), its 3rd graders beat the state by nearly 15 points in math (57.7% vs. 42.9%) and 9 points in ELA. KuehnHaven Middle School generally trails state averages, especially in math, though 4th grade math is nearly at parity.
The district’s biggest concern is equity. The Alternative Center receives just $7,013 per student—less than half of Carter’s $16,504—despite serving students with the greatest needs. Chronic absenteeism is also a hidden issue, hovering around 27-28% at all three traditional schools, matching the state average. Math struggles appear systemic, starting in middle school and persisting into high school SAT scores. Finally, HillMcCloy’s 8th graders score far below its 11th graders, suggesting either a difficult transition into high school or significant academic growth over those years. For parents, this district offers a strong elementary experience and an improving traditional high school, but the alternative program’s severe under-resourcing warrants serious attention.
Thank you for your feedback!