Summary:
This analysis examines three elementary schools in zip code 21001 (Aberdeen, MD), serving grades PK through 5 within the Harford County Public Schools district, a mid-tier district in Maryland.
Bakerfield Elementary stands out as the top performer, earning a 3-star rating and significantly outperforming its peers in nearly every subject. It boasts a remarkably low chronic absenteeism rate of 7.5% and achieves the highest proficiency in Math (32.3%), English Language Arts (57.8%), and 5th-grade Science (43.8%). In stark contrast, Halls Cross Roads Elementary has the highest level of economic disadvantage (85.88% free/reduced lunch) and the highest per-student spending ($21,588), yet it struggles with the lowest academic scores in Math and Science. G. Lisby Elementary at Hillsdale sits in the middle, with high poverty (70.27%) and the highest chronic absenteeism rate (17.7%), leading to generally below-average performance, though it shows a strength in 4th-grade English Language Arts.
A key finding is the "money vs. performance" paradox: Halls Cross Roads spends the most and has the smallest class sizes (10.4:1) but achieves the worst results, while Bakerfield spends less and has larger classes but excels. Chronic absenteeism emerges as a critical differentiator, especially when comparing Bakerfield and G. Lisby, which have nearly identical poverty rates but vastly different outcomes. All three schools also experience a significant drop in math proficiency between 3rd and 5th grade, suggesting a systemic challenge with the 5th-grade math curriculum that warrants attention.
Thank you for your feedback!