Summary
Sutton High School in Sutton, MA, is a grades 9–12 school with 367 students in the Sutton district, which is ranked 143rd of 351 Massachusetts districts. The school itself ranks 86th of 353 MA high schools in 2025–2026 — 76th percentile, 4 stars — placing it in the top quarter of the state. That is still strong, but lower than its 55th rank in 2023–2024 and 66th in 2024–2025; the 2022–2023 dip to 53rd percentile was followed by a rebound. Locally, Grafton High School ranks 66th and Nipmuc Regional High ranks 91st, so Sutton is the second-highest-ranked nearby school, just ahead of Nipmuc but behind Grafton.
In 2025–2026 10th-grade MCAS, Sutton is above the state in ELA (58.43% vs. 45.48%), math (59.55% vs. 43.73%), and science (47.06% vs. 40.50%); physics end-of-course proficiency is 63.49% vs. 46.58% statewide. Math and physics are relative strengths, though Grafton High School and Nipmuc Regional High score higher in science, and Grafton High School leads ELA. The 2024–2025 graduation rate is 95.0% and the dropout rate is 2.0%, solidly above most nearby schools, though Douglas High School and Oxford High have slightly higher graduation rates. The student-teacher ratio is 12.5, and per-student spending was $16,405 in 2020–2021 — higher than at Grafton High School but lower than at Millbury Junior/Senior High.
One watch item is low-socioeconomic-status subgroup effectiveness: it fell to the 47th percentile with 2 stars in 2025–2026, down from 79 in 2024–2025 and 75 in 2023–2024, well below Sutton’s overall 76th percentile. Female and male subgroup measures remain broadly in line with the school’s overall profile. Science is also comparatively volatile: it was below state in 2022–2023, rebounded strongly, then declined in 2025–2026 and now trails Grafton High School and Nipmuc Regional High. Data caveats: free/reduced-price lunch percentages are unavailable, Special Education subgroup data are older, and some nearby schools include grades 7–8, so 10th-grade and high-school-specific metrics are the fairest comparisons. Overall, Sutton remains a top-quartile, 4-star school with strong math, physics, and graduation outcomes, but families should watch science trends and low-socioeconomic-status support.
Thank you for your feedback!